i have just finished reading this story on ginnypotter and i have to say it is one of the best yet. thank you for creating ulysees grayson i am his no.1 fan and yours as well. keep writing. mendel p.s: i have also read your other stories including the naked potions class and the one about grayson. they are all excellent however this is your masterpiece. to everyone elsE: MAKE SURE YOU READ ODDISH'S STORIES.
very nice but why the long wait
your story is too good 4 that. 100/10 *75. mendel.
nice chapter. thanks 4 the quick update.
good chapter. it didn't seem to move things forward a lot though. keep writing. mendel.
this has to be one of the best chapters yet. keep doing wot your doing just quicker. 20/10. mendel
that was genius. i woz wondering how u would make him discover it. but this is simply beyond imagination. once again thanks 4 the super quick updates. ur the fastest updater i know. mendel.
nice. this chapter tells us a lot about the pressure that harry is feeling and the way he is coping- badly, by the sound of it.however it doesn't move the story along much and could probably be condensed into another chapter.other then that the actual chappie was good. 9/10
Author's Response: You\'re right. Only half of the chapter got posted. The other half is up now.
unbelievable. i kinda guessed this would happen when he said u said that the names showed the living and yhe dead in light and dark. but i never guessed it would be like this. keep updating. 10/10
i have but one request. please don't keep me on tenderhooks 4 the next xhapter u have no idea how long i wait 4 them
also approx how long is this story gonna be
Author's Response: Hey Mendel. Sorry about the wait on this one, I was out for 3 weeks with an unnamed disease. The next chappy goes up tomorrow. Well, submitted anyway. Who knows how long the mods will take. Or if they\'ll reject the chapter because I failed to capitalize \"Snitch\". Knaves. As for length, it\'s hard to say how many chapters there will be, but let me put it this way: If the entire story were 10 chapters long, right now we\'d be halfway through chapter 7.
brilliant once again. i like the last sentence from the diary. it really seems to fitinto rowenas charachter. 10/10. mendel.
just got chapter 19. i have been checking up on it every day!!! yet again another excellent chapter however i'm not sure i like the idea of his head being restricted, maybe where he goes yes.but to be unable to move your neck makes it seem as if rowena did not have the power to allow the reader to do so. one other point that i'd just like to get clear- is "ungifted ones" the historical term used instead of muggles. on a lighter note another simply exquisite chaoter. pleeeeeeeeze write faster. mendel
Author's Response: Thanks for the review. I've actually finished the next 5 chapters, the wait is from the mods. As for Harry's restricted view, the diary is a more primitive magic than a pensieve or Riddle's diary, and Harry is only seeing Ravenclaw's actual memory. So basically, if she didn't see it, he won't see it.
that was much better. thanks a lot. mendel.
very nice chappie, i wonder what thet last bit was about. another fantastic chapter. i like the way slytherin shows his feelings on the ungifted ones. i enjoyed this chapter much more then the previous one. keep writing. mendel
unbelievable. u should just know that 4 religious reasons i was fasting when i read this and u enlightenerd my day. foo for the mind. cheers mendel
Author's Response: Hey Mendel. I hope you\'ve eaten some real food since then. Thanks for the complement.
another great chapter. what pray tell, was unexpected and how many chapters to go. mendel.
Author's Response: Hi Mendel. Actually Crazyhpgirl was the winner. Once the current chappy is approved, we have 9 chaps to go. If this was an actual Rowling book, we are just about to the catharsis where everything takes off.
another fantastic chapter. my only worry is that g.g is a fake. please tell me this is not true as too many authors take this line and it is becoming increasingly ounoriginal. HOWEVER even if it is true i will continue reading as i am hooked. PLEASE PLEASE PLEEEAZE write faster. mendel
brilliant. two questions. firstly is this the whole of the second diary or not. and secondly is there a reason u switched to the word Muggle/s instead of your previous name for them. why does it take so long to have each chappie authorised it was never like this before. great work. keep writing. mendel.
Author's Response: Yep. That\'s the whole of the second diary. Not the end of the diaries though... As for \"Muggles\", Slytherin is the only one who uses the title freely, as it is still considered a slur to most of the wizarding public. I have no idea why it takes so long to get the chappy\'s approved. It used to take only 2-3 days. Kind of frustrating, especially since I\'ve submitted more than 25 in a row that haven\'t been rejected. Oh well. Thanks for your comments.
once agin u have outdone urself. congratulations on the baby. this time i won't hurry u up. i hope u spend all the time neccessary on him/her and that u truly enjoy it. congratulations again. and thanks 4 the update. mendel.
brilliant. i have waited simply ages for this update. why does the chapter go up when it hasn't been validated. please write faster. 10/20. mendel
Author's Response: Thanks. I have the next 5-6 chapters written, it\'s the mods that are making it take so long. One chapter took 2 weeks to get validated.