Longtime fan and writer, but not of HP.
This is the first time that I ahve reviewed any of the stories that I read, sicne I started on Mugglenet a couple of weeks ago. here goes -
Like a lot of people, I feel drawn to the H&G stories and yours is the best of the single chapter ones that I have read.
Doesn't try and get too much in too quickly as most of the others do. A nice simple, (and) believeable concept works perfectly. Just enough of a hint of what could/would be to come and makes me wish that there was more.
Have you though about expanding upon this story and filling in your own 6th and 7th years?
Well, that'll do.
Excellent story. Believeable changes made to characters, but not enough to spoil the enjoyment. Thank you.
Rose was a Weasley. She never gave Scorpius Malfoy a second glance. They were sworn enemies, even though they’d barely even spoken to each other. But sometimes all it takes for love to blossom is a Potions lesson, a few snide remarks and a dropped book.
Two people. Two entirely different worlds that are suddenly intertwined.
Now I have my login finally sorted out, i can review.
Nicely paced story and one of the best Scorpious and Rosie ones I've come across. I think you are very right to make it a little more adult themed as it reflects the age of the characters.
Keep going and I look forward to reading the next chapter.
Author's Response: Thank you for such a lovely review! I'll try to update soon. :)
Have been wondering where the sequel qould be going and am very pleased to see it now starting to come up.
A nice gentle start with enough of a hint of what's to come to keep me coming back.
Will be intrigued to see where Harry's 'new' wand will take him and how you go aboutnvanquishing Voldemort.
Author's Response: Hey thanks for the great review! I officially started rewriting everything this past weekend so chapter two is just around the corner!!!
It’s not just any 1st of September. The Philosopher Stone is hidden at Hogwarts, The Boy Who Lived is about to board the Express for the first time. It’s not the best September for something unexpected to happen, for something impossible. Or someone.
This story is not AU, but it focuses on the original character, her plot, her friends, her loves :)
Rating and Warning only for later chapters.
Interesting way of looking at Malfoy. Keeps in character, yet gives him more dimensions. Will keep reading to see where this goes.
Author's Response: Thanks! Malfoy and Snape are tricky to keep in character; comments and suggestions are always welcomed to try and improve that :)
Nice tale. Nearly had me reaching for JKR's book to see if it appeared there!
Keep it up.
Author's Response: Thanks! Complete first year is now posted :)
An excellent start. I enjoy reading 'what happened after' type stories. Let's see what does happen next...
Stop it! I'm at work and trying to stop tears in my eyes.