MuggleNet Fan Fiction
Harry Potter stories written by fans!
Reviews For Assist

Name: Dad (Signed) · Date: 09/24/14 17:39 · For: Chapter 2
I like the style.

Name: Wenlock (Signed) · Date: 09/24/14 11:53 · For: Chapter 2
I just discovered this story, and I must say, I'm glad you decided to pick up writing it again. I really hope to see you finish it because I have loved it so far.

One thing I love about this is how unique it is. There are a lot of stories about the wizarding world after the defeat of Voldemort, and a good majority of them center on the Weasley family. However, you don't see a lot of stories about the older brothers. This is probably because they are more difficult to write.
You have done a marvelous job writing Percy. You've captured his diligence and desire to impress authority figures very well. You have also done a great job showing his grief and fatigue, as well as his feelings of self-doubt and his concern for his family that is bordering on guilt. I can tell this story is well thought out. As a reader, I appreciate the level of effort you've put into this.

My favorite quote from this chapter is, "All at once, she became a little more human to him. Not that he'd consciously been thinking of her as an emotionless automaton, but other than the time the day before when he had nearly brought her to tears, she had only shown him an imperturbable, professional exterior." I don't exactly know why that passage stood out to me, but it is particularly well-written and I have a feeling it represents an important shift in thier relationship.

All in all, this story was very well written. Keep up the good work, because I really want to read more.

Name: Oregonian (Signed) · Date: 01/20/14 2:13 · For: Chapter 1
Hi, Cinderella. This is Vicki of Slytherin House. I see by your list of titles on your author’s page that you have been contributing to this forum from the very beginning and are still here. So congratulations on your loyalty and long tenure.

This chapter is a very promising start to whatever your story will turn out to be. It is only through fics such as yours that we get a mental picture of what Percy was doing at the Ministry during those final years, because in the seven books he is a pretty one-dimensional character. In stories such as yours we can get a glimpse of his soul.

You have begun to draw a perceptive picture of this poor fellow, inviting us to have sympathy with him, drained both physically and emotionally from the stress, danger and loss of the past few years. Other post-battle fics focus on Ron, George, Ginny, Arthur, and Molly Weasley, and sometimes Bill, but Percy and Charlie tend to get ignored, and I am glad that you are addressing this imbalance of attention.

You present an interesting contrast between Percy and Susan; she is calm, unruffled, and briskly efficient, while he is exhausted and overwhelmed, although too proud to admit it. I ask myself what, beyond their individual personalities, accounts for this difference? They have both lost family members, but he spent the last few years at the Ministry while she was still in school; as bad as Hogwarts was during the last few years, perhaps being in the Ministry was worse.

There is some introspection by Percy in your story, but not so much as to be oppressing (as you see in some fics), and a good balance of dialogue and action. He’s tossed her out of the office twice; I presume he will not do so again. She has given him a bottle of Dreamless Sleep potion, which he refuses to use, so we have yet to see how she is going to assist him. Not just by filing his backlog of papers, I’m sure.

I like your writing style. There is a vivid vocabulary, with many action verbs, and the net effect is a brisk pace and an easy visualization of the events. And you have a wonderful closing line. Miss Bones filed on, apparently unperturbed. This is an open-ended sentence if ever there was one. It fairly invites us to sweep on into the next chapter.

I hope that there will be a next chapter. This story has a lot of promise, and poor Percy certainly deserves to be treated sympathetically after all he’s been through. Good start.

Name: Gmariam (Signed) · Date: 02/06/13 20:43 · For: Chapter 1
I think this is a really unique take on Percy and how the war affected him. The thought that he would have nightmares after all he saw, that he would feel guilty, that he would bury himself in works just seems so right. And the idea of someone being there to help him is lovely. Making the connection between Susan Bones and the Ministry was a good one. I liked her backbone. I only wonder about her being 'Miss Bones' as it seemed to have a rather distant effect. But I'm guessing that was a distinct narrative choice and hoping that as Percy gets to know her, he'll think of her more as Susan and then it won't feel so distant. If that makes sense. :)
Nice start, good luck as you continue! ~Gina :)

You must login (register) to review.