Login
MuggleNet Fan Fiction
Harry Potter stories written by fans!
Reviews For When The Rose Fell

Name: rambkowalczyk (Signed) · Date: 11/26/12 11:27 · For: Chapter 2: Private Affairs
Wasnt sure I would like this as there are so many Rose, and Scorpius stories. So far each has his or her own voice. Good start.

Author's Response: We're really glad you think this is different, and we assure you that it really is. Thank you for the review, and hope you'll remain with us! :)


Name: Ruchira_M (Signed) · Date: 10/08/12 12:36 · For: Chapter 1: Get a Room
Please do update.

Author's Response: Hi, this is Pooja (Ginny Weasley Potter). I assure you, we are planning to update in a few days, hopefully. Nadia wrote down Rose before she left and I've started up on Scorpius-- just have to finish writing it. Then it will go to our lovely Beta and be up soon! Thank you for your patience! :)


Name: PeppermintToads (Signed) · Date: 09/16/12 3:49 · For: Chapter 1: Get a Room
Haha! I loved this!

Okay, let's start with Scorpius. I love him already. He's annoying, sarcastic, and gets all of the good lines. The line "this bititng cold you've all dam*ed us to die in" was absolutely hilarious! I also liked the ninja reference ;) The Lucius thing was totally believable and a bit sad.

On to Rose. I can already relate to her. She seema to be a smart, sensible girl much like Hermione. You can tell that she really does NOT like Scorpius (loved the implication that she would set James on him!) and I can't wait to see what changes that. I liked how she went to her best friend for everything and I really liked your Dominique!

The last line is leaving me (and many others, I am sure) eagerly awaiting more. Character developement is great and I love the plot already.

Author's Response:
Pooja: Sorry, Julie, that we're so late! You can Avada kedavra us if you like and I will accept it, promise! Anyway, I'm really glad you liked both Rose and Scorpius. I loved writing him like that. I've portrayed him in a lot of ways but this was new and very enjoyable. I have used a bit of Pottermore info in this chapter, actually, regarding the Malfoys. Ha, and I'm glad you enjoyed the jokes. Few people like my humour, understandable, as I don't have any of it. :/ As for Rose, that's Nadia's magic! She's the funny one among us and when I read how Nadia had written Rose, I giggled a lot. Update will take a while due to the chapter challenge and Nadia's hiatus, sorry! But thanks for reviewing!
Nadia: Sorry sorry sorry >.< Pooja and I are lazy bums and we kind of.... forgot :/. Sorry! *sends over chocolate cookies.* There! Hope that makes you happy :3. Ahem. Now onto my response! I'm really glad you loved both Rose and Scorpius. I really enjoyed Di's portrayal of Scorpius, for I always thought be exactly like that. An annoying, brooding little thing. Rose was really fun to write, too, and I never think that she's fall for Scorpius just like that without any hidden back story -- and that was the whole point of this fic. :) Dominique was a very cocky character, and I laughed while I wrote her. I don't know how good she was, but I really loved writing her. And updates.... *rubs hands* I don't know if we can before November, because I'm going abroad for a month and we've both had challenge stories and this could wait a bit. Hopefully we'll have another update in November. Thank you for your lovey reviews, Julie! They always manage to bring a smile on our faces. *squishes.*


Name: victoria_kate (Signed) · Date: 09/13/12 7:57 · For: Chapter 1: Get a Room
Hi, although I tend to not like this pairing I found this story to be really interesting. I hope to be able to read more soon. Good luck, and thank you both for may be changing my mind.

Author's Response:
Pooja:Thank you! I love this pairing (though occasionally, I let Scorpius have some fun with Hugo) and I'm so glad that our writing has made you like it! :)
Nadia: Yay, I'm glad you liked it! Scorose is actually my favourite pairing, and I'm glad we could (maybe) change your mind :). Thank you for the review!


Name: HumanHorcrux (Signed) · Date: 09/12/12 23:41 · For: Chapter 1: Get a Room
I think this is awesome! Two fantastic writers rolled into one. :D I was looking forward to this one- Sapphires and Rubies give any hints? :P
What year is Dom in? Will there be many more cousin-ly appearances?
I really like that "Uncle Neville's" daughter is called Alice and is Rose's best friend.
Keep up the good work!

Author's Response:
Pooja: Ooh, I've never had a reader actually look forward for one of my fics and I'm blushing right now. :) I'm so glad you liked S/R, and are enjoying this now. :) Nadia and I decided on seventh year for Dom. And there will be other cousinly appearances. You don't know how much. :P And the Alice thing was Nadia's lovely idea. I just stuck with it. :) Thank you for that lovely review!
Nadia Yay thank you so much *blushes furiously*. your review made me squee. I'm glad you liked that I named Neville's daughter Alice; Neville really loved his mother and he was very emotionally attached to her, despite her condition. This made me think he'd want to name his daughter after her, so I went along with it =). And in the matter of cousin-ly appearances... no comment! =P. I do hope that you'll continue reading and that we live up to your expectations. Thank you so, so much for the lovely review! :D


Name: Dad (Signed) · Date: 09/12/12 16:58 · For: Chapter 1: Get a Room
I think the answer to the last sentence is "everybody who reads this story".

Author's Response:
Nadia: lol. I must say that I agree! I hope you continue to read on. :D Thankyou!
Pooja:Thank you for reading and reviewing! And you're so right, LOL.


You must login (register) to review.