MuggleNet Fan Fiction
Harry Potter stories written by fans!
Reviews For Sapphires

Name: The_Real_Hermione (Signed) · Date: 04/16/13 23:53 · For: One-Shot
This was a really interesting concept, to connect four completely different couples through the colour blue, and I liked how you used blue as a representation of trust and used that as the common theme. It felt like a bit of a refrain, which I thought worked really well.

I know these were just meant to be snapshots, but I would have liked a bit more of Albus' story - I think you mentioned her name (Andrea) once, but I would have liked to have known more about her character and their relationship together. But I thought the section was well-written and showed his sadness and regret - or at least wish that he could change something. That was evoked really well.

I thought the Scorpius/Rose section worked really well - it was very complete, even though you didn't show that much of their relationship, because from what you did show they were really in love with each other. I thought it was sad that they both got married without their fathers' approvals, although it drew a nice link between them that both their fathers were against it and both their mothers agreed. And I felt like there was some hope that their fathers might come around to the idea. Rose writing that message on the handkerchief felt very heartfelt.

I likd Parvati and Danyal's story - it's nice to read a fanfic with forbidden love that's not about Purebloods/muggleborns.You really showed Parvati's unhappiness about it, and so I really felt her joy when she realised that she would actually be with the man she loved - it was very romantic and sweet. It might have been nice to see a bit more aobut their religions though - clearly Parvati believes in her religion, and it would be interesting to explore the conflict that might be there between them, not just their families. I hope that makes sense. But as a snapshot it did work really well.

The last part really went somewhere I wasn't expecting, but the way you set Genevieve's character up, I really understood why she did that. I liked the way you explored the idea of power and victimhood - because initially Genevieve seems like the powerless one, but in the end she turns the tables on him, and I think she gets her strength from her child - which I interpret as being love which ultimately causes her to do that. Because before she was pregnant, she didn't really have anything to live for.

Just one little thing - I didn't like the opening few lines of the story that much. I would have liked it more if you'd got straight into the characters and maybe incorporated in later the different meanings of the colour blue. I just didn't feel that drawn in initially.

I actually came to this story because you both left me such lovely reviews, but I really enjoyed it so I'll be going to read more of both of your stuff soon. :).


Author's Response: Pooja:

Hey Katrina! Thank you for that amazing review! This was actually for a challenge, and since Nadia and I liked the themes it suggested, we chose the blue colour. Nadia wrote Albus and Mrs Zabini, and she’ll be responding to you about those, while I’ll stick to Scorpius and Parvati. Although I have to tell you- she does have a wonderful Albus/Andrea story called ‘Patchwork’, and is planning on writing them properly in another story too.

For Scorpius and Rose, it was just like a drabble, to be honest. It continues in Rubies, the sequel to this, and I really felt that there was nothing to add after that. I felt that Rose would be closer to her father than her mother, hence, she’d feel terrible if he didn’t accept her marriage. But then again, she trusted her relationship with Scorpius, so I guess she decided to go with it. I think Ron would forgive her when later on. :) I am glad you liked it, though.

The Parvati/Danyal theme is a very common, and very real thing in India. People die over this kind of thing, and this, in comparison, is pretty mild, actually. Well, as Nadia and I wrote this story in a rush, it didn’t leave much time to explore the intricacies of the religious conflicts here. But yes, it was mainly to explore a story theme I hadn’t really done before, as I don’t write religion much. But then again, you liked it, and nothing makes me happier!

Again, thank you for the amazing review! :D It really made both our days. The sequel is called Rubies, if you want to check it out, and though I haven’t expanded upon my snippets, Nadia has written another Albus and Andrea story, like I’ve said. Thank you! *hearts*

Nadia:Katrina, thank you! This review is really nice, and I'm glad you liked the story. I am glad you agree with me about Genevieve; that's exactly the effect I was hoping for. I wanted to show that, though people think that Mrs Zabini was an evil person, she was the victim of it. I've wondered about her a lot, and I find this to be a plausible answer. It's true that after her child came, she couldn't take it anymore and whatever she did, was for him and to provide him a better life. This, probably, is what caused a series of events that lead to each husband's death. I think that maybe initially she killed him to protect her son, but later with her other husbands, I guess she just got the thrill and realised she liked doing it. But yes, overall in this scene, she did it all for her son. I tried to show her courage here, and I'm happy you picked it up :)

As for Al and Andrea, I have written a story about them! It's called Patchwork, and it shows how they got together. I'm also planning on a sequel and a prequel to this, too; at least I'll write it once I'm over my major writers block, hah. Anyway, thank you so much for the lovely review! I'm glad you liked our story! Don't forget to check out part II of this, though! This won't make much sense without it :) Thanks again, Katrina! <3

Name: PeppermintToads (Signed) · Date: 08/16/12 2:18 · For: One-Shot
This was beautiful. All of these are sad and happy and wonderful in their own ways. You two wrote to your strengths and it was perfect! Great job, Nadia and Pooja!

Author's Response:
Pooja - Thank you for that wonderful review, Julie! I... really have no words! Just, thanks so much and I'm so glad you liked this! (:
Nadia - Yay Julie, I'm glad you liked it! :D Pooja and I did, actually, decide to write the parts we could write best. Thank you for the awesome review! *hearts*

Name: baby54boomer (Signed) · Date: 08/15/12 12:33 · For: One-Shot
Disconnect...sorry. The premise of using "blue" would have been much more complete had you intertwined your characters' stories together, not created four distinct mini-tales.

Author's Response:
Pooja - Blue represents trust and that was actually the connection between the four stories. We didn't want any other connection as such. Thank you for your comment!
Nadia - We found that the four characters were more fun to write about :). And we wanted to show how Blue meant differently for different people - separate incidents of peace, trust, sadness and bitterness, with trust playing the pivotal part in all four. It would seem like an overload to put all these emotions in one story. Thanks for the review! :D

Name: zhengjiamei (Signed) · Date: 08/15/12 11:11 · For: One-Shot
awesome writing!! i loved how this featured different characters :) can't wait for the next one. :)

Author's Response:
Pooja - Thank you! I'm glad that you liked our idea for the four different characters! 'Rubies' is coming up soon!

Nadia - Yay, I'm glad you liked the story! Thanks for the review! :D

Name: HumanHorcrux (Signed) · Date: 08/15/12 4:08 · For: One-Shot
Ooohhh! I can't wait for Rubies! This was written very well. Keep up the good work! :D

Author's Response: Pooja: Squee! I'm so glad you liked this! Rubies and much more from us coming up soon!

Nadia: Yay, I'm glad you liked it :D. This was a lot of fun to write and I'm glad staying up half the night AIM-ing the whole story paid off :P lol. Thanks for the review! :)

You must login (register) to review.