Reviewer: AidaLuthien
Date: 11/28/10 15:56
Chapter: Chapter 1

This is a really interesting take on a minor character. I really enjoyed how you've expanded Marietta's backstory.

I'm not sure I can piece together the Marietta in your story with the one we see in canon. It's not that I find fault with your characterization of her within your one-shot, that makes perfect sense, but I'm not sure how she makes the jump from this very determined to do Something, to turning in the DA. There's no hints of what might make her change her mind so completely.

I do like that you've taken a character that is canonically very minor and not particularly likable and made her likable and understandable.

Now for two little nitpicks. First, here: "Fat-ass belly, she commented mentally." As my beta keeps telling me, thoughts have to be in italics. Second, the very last line of the story reads "But there was on thing" It should be one thing. It drove me crazy because it's the very last line and it just took me right out of the story.

Some of your lines were really brilliant though. I really liked this one: "She managed it, barely, a thousand scathing remarks restrained just behind her teeth" and this one, "too slow to be one of the petit allegros her ballet mistress had insisted were vital to build stamina".

All in all, this was a very enjoyable little one-shot.

Reviewer: darkchocolatemntn
Date: 08/16/09 18:21
Chapter: Chapter 1

good job, very well written, but if she liked cedric and cho so much, and was so mad at her mom, and wanting Voldemorte to die, why would she tell on the DA?

Author's Response: A lot changes in eight months. Parental pressure can be very hard to resist.

Reviewer: Hermiones_Therapist
Date: 08/16/09 13:38
Chapter: Chapter 1

This is excellent. Interesting premise, awesome charaterization, great writing. Great story.

Author's Response: Thanks very much!

You must login (register) to review.
Information
Find out everything you need to know about the site right here.


We have stories and authors in this archive.

:

RSS
Choose Theme:
MOST RECENT
The Interview by HalfASlug 3rd-5th Years
10th November, 1981. Severus Snape has been summoned to Hogwarts for the first...
The Final Duel by BrokenPromise 1st-2nd Years
A sonnet on the Battle of Hogwarts.
Sophomore Spells at the Wizarding University of Paris by jenniferes Professors
Hermione Granger and Draco Malfoy attend their sophomore year at the Wizarding...
FEATURED
When Saints Die, The World Stops Spinning by forsakenphoenix 1st-2nd Years
Hope, loyalty, love, despair, and tragedy. Through it all, Lily discovers the...
The Seven Potters by Gmariam 1st-2nd Years
Harry is about to leave the Burrow for the final time when his six doppelgangers...
Doubt by lucca4 3rd-5th Years
In the midst of the war, the Marauders and Lily have joined the Order, resolute...
Rest In The Bed by welshdevondragon 3rd-5th Years
"This is the last night I will spend in our flat. I have spent sixty-nine nights...
Marriage and Other Matters by Acacia Carter 3rd-5th Years
All Augusta wanted to do was apologise, but the minute she opened her mouth...
Chased by Daylight by iLuna17 3rd-5th Years
In the morning, she knows he'll never be there. This is for Maple, as a...
When You Think of Umbridge by hestiajones 1st-2nd Years
How Umbridge sees herself and wants to be seen - a speculation in prose poem...
Empty Chairs at Empty Tables by The_Real_Hermione 3rd-5th Years
In November 1981, Remus Lupin returns to the headquarters of the Order of the...
CATEGORIES