Reviews For Seeking a Reason
Reviewer: Crystal99
Date: 09/16/10 14:33
Chapter: Chapter 6: The Note

I wonder if James really did send that letter to try to get Libby into bed. Only time will tell. Poor Cecelia, being roped into kissing Daniel. Although she did enjoy the kiss. You write a Quidditch scene so much better then I ever could. I enjoyed reading this chapter. Nicely done, mzap. :)

Author's Response: Crystal! It's great to see you back! I'm glad you liked the chapter and the Quidditch scene. I find them the most difficult to write. Thanks for reading and reviewing! :)

Reviewer: CloverSun
Date: 08/16/10 20:13
Chapter: Chapter 6: The Note

OMG!!!! IT's sooo gooda281;a281;a281;a281;a281;a281;a281;a281; Can't wait to see morea281;a281;a281;a281;a281;a281;a281;

Author's Response: Thanks, CloverSun! :) I'm glad you liked it and I'll be sure to update soon. :)

Reviewer: karamarie
Date: 08/16/10 0:53
Chapter: Chapter 6: The Note

it was such a pleasant surprise to see a new chapter! i am intrigued to find out what james is up to.

Author's Response: Thanks karamarie! :) I'll be sure to update soon so you can see what James is up to. :)

Reviewer: Loonyluna09
Date: 08/10/10 23:38
Chapter: Chapter 6: The Note

this was a good story but i feel like there needs to be more to it

Author's Response: Thanks for the review, Loonyluna! I'm always trying to improve, so are there any suggestions you had in mind? Thanks again. :)

Reviewer: ToBeOrNotToBeAGryffindor
Date: 07/25/10 17:21
Chapter: Chapter 6: The Note

Oh, yeah!!! Update. :D

You write the gameplay for Quidditch so very well. The way it flows just makes for wonderful imagery. 

So, James is supposedly turning over a new leaf? Haha, I don't buy it for a second. He'll be insufferable until time stops. I can't wait to find out what happens between Libby and him.

Take care and happy writing!


Author's Response: Thanks, Jess! It took me a while to try and write the gameplay; so much to think about! I'm glad you liked that. Haha about James and you'll see soon what happens between them. Thanks again for reading and reviewing, Jess! :) I love hearing your comments.

Reviewer: karamarie
Date: 05/25/10 6:06
Chapter: Chapter 5: The Visit

i am in love with this story. this was such a cute chapter. i do hope you update soon...please!!!

Author's Response: Thank you so much! I promise I'll update as soon as I can. Thanks for reading and reviewing! :)

Reviewer: ToBeOrNotToBeAGryffindor
Date: 04/09/10 10:15
Chapter: Chapter 5: The Visit

Oi, Mercy! You have impeccable timing, my dear. All of my all-time favourite fics always seem to get updated right about the time that I’m looking for something to read and review, which usually seems to save me from reading something new and potentially not quite as entertaining.

I’ve left reviews before, but I’ve decided that, since I love this story – and James Potter – so much, I’m going to leave you a proper review for a change, so here goes. I’m going to address certain things that I noticed while reading (I re-read the whole thing first), and then I’ll sum up characters and overall events.

He was on the other side of the pitch, blue eyes looking directly at her, or more like glaring.

This is from the Prologue. I know it’s a nit-pick and all, but I’m very curious as to how James could have blue eyes. Ginny has brown eyes, which is a dominant trait (which carries a 75% chance of having it), and Harry has green (a recessive genome –there is only a 25% chance of getting it). It’s been established in canon that Albus is the only one with green eyes, so that would make it more than probable that both James and Lily have brown eyes, as well, considering the fact that Harry also carries a recessed brown eye genome that he inherited from his father (bringing the chances of another eye colour than brown down from 25% to 6.25%). That being said, Ginny does carry the blue eye genome, which is yet another recessive genome, because Ron had blue eyes, so he had to get it from somewhere. I was just wondering if this was a conscious decision to give him blue eyes, despite his genetic predisposition for brown or it just wasn’t something you particularly cared to addle your brain with (trust me, my head is spinning with genomes right now, lol).

I love the ‘my dad can beat up your dad’ aspect between Libby and James. It was definitely worth a chuckle, and it definitely cements James’s role in this story as a (not so) villain type. He’s hot, he’s rich, he’s famous, he goes through Snitch bunnies (a Quidditch version of puck bunnies or B-bunnies, I suppose) like tissues, and he’s a bit of a jerk.

Libby shifted in her chair and beamed. “One could say that, but I’d like to think that they’re still a lot more ahead for me.”

This is probably supposed to be ‘there’s’.

The small details that you put in the story, such as Felix’s hair changing colours when he’s embarrassed is fantastic. It takes that wonderful gift of being a Metamorphmagus and shows the everyday applications and foibles of having this particular ability.

The song that Cecelia sang in the pub was lovely, by the way. I know it was written in honour of Remus and Tonks, but it seemed to me that it also carried foreshadowing of something more between James and Libby, such as:

“They call you dangerous,”

“Beneath the monster is a kind-hearted man
And among the girls, you’re in high demand
But they don’t understand you
As I do.”

Then again, I may be reading way too much into it, but those lines fit Libby’s relationship with James (if one could even call it that) almost to a tee. ‘Calling him dangerous’ is like her friends telling her not to perpetuate her feud with him, and the rest, it seems like it matches Chapter 5 when she goes to see him and he seems like a whole different person when they call a truce. The part about the girls is, er, pretty obvious, and Libby does, in a way, understand James better than most people, because as much as they’d hate to admit it, they’re a lot alike in many respects. They’re both arrogant, not willing to back down once their hackles have been raised, and neither likes to lose at anything, let alone just Quidditch.

All right, now that that’s done, I’d like to address the characters. First off, Libby is a great OC. She’s sexy, spunky, competitive, and arrogant, but those are tempered by the kinder aspects of her nature, such as loyalty to her friends and her ridiculous habit of blushing when she’s around Felix. The story is so much more compelling because she’s not perfect, she’s not a ‘victim’ of James’s public barbs, and I have a feeling of ‘well, you get what you give’ when things between her and James flare up.

The borderline alcohol abuse is actually quite realistic to me, because how many 20 year old celebrities fall into the substance abuse track? While there are far worse pitfalls to which she has not succumbed, it adds a dimension of truth and realism to her character.

Felix is absolutely adorable. He likes Libby, which is so obvious, but he is, in the true fashion of a boy that’s fancied a girl for that long, a complete coward about showing it or acting on it. He has this magnetism that sort of sucks me in, making me want him to end up with Libby, even though I really want her with James deep down. I can’t help but wonder which one he takes after more: Remus or Tonks. Either way, he makes me smile. :D

I really like the fact that Libby’s friend/cousins aren’t completely bowled over about her being famous. They even take the mickey out of her for it at times, which is the mark of someone who’s known you since you were barely old enough to stand up straight.

Hamish is a very interesting character. He’s a caring father, but he’s also a Quidditch star and Captain at the same time. The scene when he and Libby practise early in the morning is such a great barometer of their relationship. He’s still concerned about her being a good player, but he doesn’t take the fun out of it, as parents with athletically gifted children tend to do. Also, his reaction to Libby’s injury, even though it was by no mean the first, really brings out the protective side of him. That and the Daniel incident… lol.

I love the run-in with Albus. He is, of course, my favourite character of all, even if I’m not an Epilogue fan. That’s why I’m so glad you portrayed him the way you did. He isn’t some flash and dash fellow like James, and he’s not what one would deem attractive (and most forget that Harry wasn’t exactly Brad Pitt, either). He’s just a nice guy that cares about his family and friends. Very well done.

And then there’s the rather awkward meeting of the two at the end of Chapter 5. I knew this all had to come to a head, and you definitely delivered. I really loved the awkward tension between them, especially when they made contact. And then when he was checking her out, which I believe was unintentional on his part, I was torn between laughing at Libby’s outrage and wanting James to shag her brains out until they made nice. The dynamic between the two of them is just so electric, I can’t help but want her with James, no matter how sweet and nice Felix is. He just can’t hold a candle to that appeal that comes with the messy black hair… buuuuuut, I digress.

Anyway, fabulous story so far, and shame on people for not reading and reviewing it more. I think 4 of the reviews for this were already mine (fail, MNFF readers!), and I really hope that you finish this story, at least to put me out of my misery, because I really, really want to know who Libby ends up with – if anyone at all.

Cheers and happy writing, and I hope this finds you in good spirits!


Author's Response: Thank you so incredibly much! I believe this is one of the nicest reviews anyone's ever left me, and I'm so thankful that you took the time to write it. Lol, you've found stuff in this story that I didn't even realize when I wrote it. Hmmm... where to begin.... - For James' eye color, I can't remember how I came up with that, but it must have been because I wanted that gene to crop up again (even though ignoring the genetics is especially embarrassing coming from a pre-med student). - You definitely nailed it about James not entirely being a "villain"; he is a jerk, but that's not his only side and I didn't want him to become a full-blown antagonist (that's for my other works, haha). - For Felix's hair, I think I had that for Teddy in a previous fic and the trait just stuck with me; I just imagine it being slightly difficult to control one's hair or other features while being in an emotional situation... particularly when you're in the presence of someone you like. - The song... I really, really hadn't thought of that before, but that idea's brilliant! I just wrote it as it came to my mind, and I'm not all that poetic either.... But you are right about them being very much alike, which is definitely making the decision difficult. - Once again, you've nailed my characters, all of them. Haha, oh, Hamish... I still remember writing him as a teenager... such a jock, but he likes being a daddy very much. - As for Chapter 5, I love that bit, too, especially since they've been fighting for so long... as for them sleeping together... teehee. xD Again, thank you so very much for this review. It really made my morning and I'm so happy that you've been enjoying this story so much. :) - Mercy

Reviewer: Crystal99
Date: 04/05/10 18:00
Chapter: Chapter 5: The Visit

I'm glad Libby and James called a truce. Now maybe they can finally get along. I wouldn't be surprised if they fell for each other despite the age difference. I enjoyed the chapter and am looking forward to the next one. Nicely done.

Author's Response: Thanks, Crystal! Yes, hopefully this truce will allow them to put some things behind them and perhaps something else could happen to. ;) Thanks again for the review! :)

Reviewer: meldina
Date: 04/04/10 16:25
Chapter: Chapter 5: The Visit

Oh hunny post gosh goodnessly

Author's Response: Thank you, meldina! I'll be sure to post more soon. :)

Reviewer: MissTiquelle
Date: 01/03/10 14:42
Chapter: Chapter 4: The Hospital

Can't wait to read more of this story!
I love how everyone always arrives with Felix and Libby like about to do something xD. Love Felix always bringing in the flowers! He's really sweet like that :).

And Daniel is quite like Cormac, I agree with Crystal99 on that one! I'm just wondering bad he actually is. Cancelling a date to hold practise though...Cecilia is better off without him :).

Author's Response: It's always fun how close the entire family is, so avoiding them all (or at least keeping a secret from them) is always hard to manage. Felix is a sweetheart and so fun how opposite he is of James. Daniel is rather arrogant, but Cecelia's always been back and forth about him and can never stay away for too long. ;) Thanks for reading and reviewing! :)

Reviewer: MissTiquelle
Date: 01/03/10 14:36
Chapter: Chapter 3: The Theatre

So I'm not reviewing EVERY chapter now, but I am reading this story and liking it :).

Just a note, they're not called cell phones in England, they're called mobiles/mobile phones.

Libby is great! I like her :). Actually, I like a lot of your OCs! Keep up the awesome work mzap :).

Author's Response: Thank you! Good to know that little detail, haha. Oh, Libby's quite a character; rather interesting to write about. Thank you for the review and for reading! :)

Reviewer: Crystal99
Date: 11/08/09 9:33
Chapter: Chapter 4: The Hospital

That Daniel Livingston fellow reminds me a little of Cormac McLaggen. It was sweet of Felix to bring Libby flowers. I wish everyone hadn't barged in on them. I would like to have seen what would have happened between them. I enjoyed reading this chapter and I'm looking forward to the next one. Nicely done, mzap. :)

Author's Response: Thanks for the reply, Crystal! Yes, Daniel is a bit like Cormac, but I like him that way. And it was sweet of Felix to bring flowers; however, if everyone hadn't barged in on them, I doubt much would have happened between Felix and Libby. ;) Thanks again for reading and replying! :)

Reviewer: ToBeOrNotToBeAGryffindor
Date: 11/02/09 17:07
Chapter: Chapter 4: The Hospital

Ah, a much-anticipated update!!!

One of the things I appreciate the most about your story is how the protagonists/main characters aren't perfect people. Harry was characterized as having a 'saving people thing' like it was some sort of vice, but real people aren't like that. I like how James is sort of a jerk and Libby has a borderline substance abuse problem, because it makes them more real.

I adore the excerpt, and I can't wait for more. :D


Author's Response: Thank you so very much! I quite like the flaws in these characters too, as it makes it quite fun to write them. Thank you again for the review and for reading! :)

Reviewer: Hermiones_Therapist
Date: 08/18/09 15:58
Chapter: Prologue

This is pretty cool.

Quick question: If Libby is 17 here, how old is James?

Author's Response: Thanks so much for reading and replying. James is about 34 in this chapter, and 37 for the rest. Thanks again. :)

Reviewer: Crystal99
Date: 08/12/09 9:38
Chapter: Chapter 3: The Theatre

I thought it was funny how Bernadette started stuttering after Rolf kissed her. I can't believe James told a magazine that Libby was a drunk. I'm looking forward to reading more of this. Nice job mzap.

Author's Response: Thanks for reading, Crystal. I happen to love the idea of Rolf and Bernadette together. They remind me very much of how Bernadette's parents were. Ah, James. *sigh* What am I going to do with him? Thanks for the review and I'm glad you liked it. :)

Reviewer: Crystal99
Date: 07/15/09 10:03
Chapter: Chapter 2: The Cafe

Poor Libby. She can't go anywhere without paparazzi following her. I hope nothing bad happens because of them. I liked the lyrics to the song Cecelia sang. It did remind me of Remus and Tonks. Lol, I thought it was cute how Ceceilia blamed her clumsiness on Tonks. I enjoyed reading and I'm looking forward to the next chapter. I hope Libby and Felix will get together soon. Nice job mzap.

Author's Response: The paparazzi won't be too much of a problem here. And thank you for the compliment on the song. :) Thanks for reading! :)

Reviewer: Crystal99
Date: 07/15/09 9:53
Chapter: Chapter 1: The Interview

I'm glad Libby didn't go on a date with Tim. He probably would have written about it in the magazine. I enjoyed the whole scene between Libby and Felix toward the end. I hope they will get together. Nice job mzap. I'm off to read more of this excellent story.

Author's Response: Thank you, Crystal. Yes, Felix and Libby are rather sweet together. Thanks again for reading! :)

Reviewer: Crystal99
Date: 07/15/09 9:43
Chapter: Prologue

Ah, so Hamish and Diana got married and had children. I enjoyed reading the Prologue. I'm off now to read more of this story. Nice job mzap.

Author's Response: Well, maybe.... It is still uncertain. ;) Actually, even though this has some of the same characters as A Mix of Alliances and Sentiments, all the problems that arise in that story are disregarded. Thanks for reading! :)

Reviewer: Windy Silvermist
Date: 06/24/09 14:53
Chapter: Chapter 2: The Cafe

Please please please please say she doesn't end up with James. I LIKE FELIX!!!!!!!!!!!!! Don't break his poor little heart.

-WIndy who like all people of Lupin

Author's Response: Thanks for reading! I'm glad you liked it and we'll have to see who Libby ends up with. As for the Lupins, I also have a soft spot for all three generations. Thanks again for the response. :)

Reviewer: ron lover
Date: 06/23/09 10:37
Chapter: Chapter 2: The Cafe

Felix is so cute! I can't wait to find out what happens next, especially with Libby and Felix. I love James too. I really like this story. I think it's cool.

Author's Response: Thank you again for reading! I agree that Felix is cute. Thank you for your compliment. :)

You must login (register) to review.
Find out everything you need to know about the site right here.

We have stories and authors in this archive.


Choose Theme:
A Story for Charlie by Darkness Enshrouds 3rd-5th Years
A boy. A girl. A budding romance. If only things never got complicated... (Violence...
Scorpius Malfoy and the Salem Witch Trials by Hotrav 3rd-5th Years
The third story in the Scorpius Malfoy and the Sins of the Fathers series. Lucius...
No One Can Ever Know by Nagini Riddle 3rd-5th Years
"My word, Severus, that I shall never reveal the best of you?"~Dumbledore to...
My Troubled Tyrant by Belledeg Professors
Keedie Dante has experienced many amazing things during her time at Hogwarts...
His and Hers by Acacia Carter 3rd-5th Years
In a perfect world, Neville and Hannah's wedding would go off without a hitch...
All This Waiting For The Sky To Fall by Dawnie 1st-2nd Years
They found her body - broken, bleeding, face filled with signs of pain and fear...
Sanguini, the Vampire by teh tarik 6th-7th Years
Vampirism is the persistence and the perpetuity of the body, a madness of the...
Lost and Found by ToBeOrNotToBeAGryffindor 3rd-5th Years
When Tracey Davis's financial security was a casualty of war, her family is...