Reviewer: RitaSkeeterWannaB
Date: 01/30/08 18:34
Chapter: Chapter 25 - The Return of the Monster
just when i though it couldnt get any better!!
Author's Response: I aim to please. Thanks for the review!
Reviewer: Chimeara169
Date: 01/30/08 18:27
Chapter: Chapter 25 - The Return of the Monster
Wow. That was unexpected. You've probably made a few enemies with that one. Not me, though! Its refreshing, although I wasn't expecting most of that. Ill trust in the infinite wisdom of the author, and hopefully everything will turn out somewhat alright! Good job on another well done chapter!
Author's Response: And so my goal was achieved, lol. I'm glad I could put a kink in your expectations. Thanks for the compliments and I hope I can keep it up :)
Reviewer: sophiewalpole
Date: 01/30/08 16:58
Chapter: Chapter 25 - The Return of the Monster
for some reason i didnt leave a review for the last chapter, but i have to comment on it now, it was a really good chapter, i am so glad that he three muskateers are back in action. where ever did you get the name Elina for the baby it is a beautiful name. Now onto this chapter, go on harry, he deserves to be taking his mind off ginny for once, i just hope its not for too long, because they are destined to be together. i hope that ron is ok aswell, for hermione and the baby's sake, he needs to be. keep the chapters coming because this has got to be one of the best. i look forward to the next one. hope you had a lovely christmas and new year.
Author's Response: I got the name Elina from Catherine Zeta Jones' character in Zorro. Her name was Elena in that movie, but I thought Elena sounded a bit too Spanish so I changed an E to an I. I had a few other choices lined up, but after seeing Elina written on paper a few times, I fell in love with it.
Thanks for all your wonderful comments, I do appreciate them. I would also like to thank you for pointing out something that I hadn't thought about in the next chapter. You were hoping that Ron is ok, and even though he does end up fine, I actually never really say so in the next chapter, lol. He does have a small part coming up that lets you know he's back to his old goofy self though, so I'll probably only say something in the author's notes.
Thanks for the review and I'm glad you're liking the story so far!
Reviewer: mirimos
Date: 01/30/08 16:10
Chapter: Chapter 25 - The Return of the Monster
lol. Nice twist there but my only problem is I have a problem with girls being taller then the guys they date so maybe harry can magic his height to hers or a bit taller?
Lemme guess here...Gavin and Susan end up together and Harry and Ginny? ...and GInny is now going to be jealous of Susan because harry pays attention to her and gets those kind of thoughts of her instead of GInny. :) I try..
Good chapter once again but IT TOOK FOREVER took come through!!! Not your fault i know but :P update again please ;)
Author's Response: Oh, come on, the girl can be taller. My whole reasoning behind her turning out to be tall like a model was to put some contrast in the differences between her and Ginny. I've always seen Ginny as a shorter, petite little spitfire, and I wanted Susan to be as refreshing to Harry as possible.
I've already said that Harry and Ginny will get together, but where Susan and Gavin are concerned? Remember, I've always tried my best to stay away from the cliches and the expectations. That's all I've got to say about that :)
As for the jealousy issue between Ginny and Susan, let me just say that I'm expecting a few negative reviews on what I put Ginny through. I've put Harry's emotions through the wringer so badly that he was basically driven insane. And when I wrote the story, I wanted Ginny to go through something almost, if not equally, traumatic. You'll just have to wait and see what it is :P
And yes, it did take a while for the approval to go through, but I think they're still having problems with the cleaning theyve been doing around here. A couple of my chapters have magically ended up double spaced and my submitted chapters are seeing a few extra html tags that weren't there before. Hopefully they can resolve this issue soon.
Thanks for the review and I'll see you next chapter!
Reviewer: smileatme890
Date: 01/30/08 15:53
Chapter: Chapter 25 - The Return of the Monster
That was a really good chapter! I hate the idea of Harry liking or being with anyone else other than Ginny, but I know it has to happen for a reason. I wasn't expecting Susan Bones to be the girl though. That really surprised me. I feel bad for Ginny though cause she could hear Harry's thoughts. But Harry had to deal with Gavin so she can deal with Susan. I am really looking forward to the next chapter!!!
Author's Response: Ah a reviewer after my own heart. You've got it all down exactly how I meant it to be. I'm glad I could surprise you with Susan too. Thanks for the review!
Reviewer: Time Shifter
Date: 01/30/08 15:32
Chapter: Chapter 25 - The Return of the Monster
Oh, wow. I did NOT see that coming. I mean Susan appearing, not the kiss at the end; once he'd noticed her physique, I saw where it was going, but you definitely caught me by surprise. By now I feel bad. Susan seems really nice, and while I'm glad you'll be ending this Harry/Ginny, I don't want her to get hurt. Gavin, sure; he seems like a jerk, and it's obvious Ginny doesn't love him, but Susan's too kind to be hurt. Hopefully she makes it out of this ok. Now you've got me eager for the next chapter!
Author's Response: Good, I'm glad I could surprise you. I take pride in doing the unexpected. And yes, Susan is and always will be the sweet girl that I've portrayed her as... and it's unfortunate that her feelings might get hurt in the future... but hopefully I can pull it off with a few more surprises where those events are concerned.
I'll have the next chapter uploaded and awaiting approval within the next 24 hours. Thanks for reading!
Reviewer: water_engel
Date: 01/30/08 15:31
Chapter: Chapter 25 - The Return of the Monster
Just to let you know I'm not made at what you put, I can't wait see find out Ginny's reaction though!!! try to update really really really really really really really fast!!!!
Author's Response: lol, thanks for not being mad at me, but don't put your angry words away yet, there's still another controversial chapter or two coming up, in which you'll see just how Ginny reacts to this new development.
And I promise to update as fast as possible, but the wait times are mostly due to the approval process. Thanks for taking the time to review!
Reviewer: the_boy_who_lives
Date: 01/30/08 14:37
Chapter: Chapter 25 - The Return of the Monster
oh, by the way
the tytle of this chapter is awesome...
"ther return of the monster" after so many years.....
10/10
Author's Response: You're the first person to give me a comment about my chapter titles. I'm glad you liked this one. I try and name my chapters according to what happens in them, and this one just seemed to be perfect. Thanks!
Reviewer: the_boy_who_lives
Date: 01/30/08 14:27
Chapter: Chapter 25 - The Return of the Monster
wow.....
we are finding a substitute of Ginny(forget Ginny for now... it is for your own good)
the character of Susan is the nearest one who can match up with Harry...
good choice....lol
Author's Response: Yup, it took me a while to figure out just who would be Harry's new love interest, but as soon as I saw what few lines Susan had in OoTP, I "fell in love" with her myself. Their small interactions in the fifth book fit with my story perfectly, and I knew there could be no other.
Thanks for your compliments and thanks for the review!
Reviewer: GinnySavesHarry1998
Date: 01/30/08 13:38
Chapter: Chapter 25 - The Return of the Monster
Um... ok, I know you said to never fear, and I know this is a Harry/Ginny story, but I am upset. It's a good, well-written chapter though. I just can't stand the idea of anybody else with Harry. Well, it doesn't really bother me as much in stories where Harry still often thinks of Ginny and compares the girl to Ginny, and she always comes up short. It doesn't seem like that with him saying/thinking the things he is, like "the softest lips he had ever felt" for example. I'm definitely staying with the story though. I have faith in Harry/Ginny and you. You wouldn't lie to us. :) Although please don't put us through the torture for too long (hopefully only a chapter or two?). I also really hope the resolution of Harry choosing between the two doesn't have Susan dying. That would be too cliche, and I think Ginny deserves to have Harry choose to be with her even if there's another amazing girl around, and they can hear each other's thoughts for crying out loud. Only the thought of Ginny in danger could throw Harry so over the edge... he could never, ever feel even close to that much for another girl. Harry and Ginny are soulmates, in canon and in your story, even if they both get a little lost along the way and become attracted to other people, as everyone is bound to be at one point or another.
Author's Response: Thank you, thank you, thank you for not jumping to conclusions, lol. My plan for the Ginny/Susan comparison in Harry's mind will be definitive. And there will be no mistake in the future on why he chooses Ginny over Susan, but so far, this chapter is just an introduction into Harry's newfound "sane-ness".
The grittier details of this newly formed love triangle (or quadrangle) will be described in the next two chapters, but there are tough times ahead for the four people involved.
Some of you expect Susan or Gavin to die, or to turn bad, but the fact that you expect it makes those situations a bit cliche. I will be doing my best to keep you on your toes and keep you guessing. Hopefully it turns out well in the ene.
You've gotten the right idea when you pointed out that they can hear each others' thoughts. I won't go into details, but the connection between Harry and Ginny will play a big part in how these relationships develop. I can tell you right now that some of it won't be pretty though, so brace yourselves.
Your last sentence there about being attracted to other people is the key here. It happens in reality and I wanted to try and bring a bit of harsh reality into the story. But like I keep promising, all will be well in the end. I know I'm sounding like a broken record, and that I might be giving a bit of the story away, but I wanted to be clear on the direction I'm taking, while at the same time filling in the plot details with something the readers might like.
Wow, that was a long response, thanks for reading and I'll have the next chapter uploaded for approval today or tomorrow!
Reviewer: brittany18baby
Date: 01/26/08 16:11
Chapter: Chapter 24 - The Ides of March
Great as usual! I'm happy that Harry and Ginny are on speaking terms again. Maybe they'll get back together again! The trio finally destroyed a horcrux! How much time has passed since harry left hogwarts? I've lost track. Thanks
Author's Response: There's no 'maybe' involved. I've said from the beginning that they'll be together in the end. I just want to make sure that the path to that goal is unique and original. Hopefully I can pull it off.
We are a little bit over 4 years past the events of the first chapter, but there will be a big time jump coming up in the next couple chapters. The final battle will take place just before the story reaches 7 years.
Thanks for reading and I'll see you next chapter.
Reviewer: papakis156
Date: 01/26/08 7:39
Chapter: Chapter 24 - The Ides of March
this story is the best i have red for quite some time now, great idea on the whole
Author's Response: Thank you very much. I've tried my best to make it somewhat refreshing and I hope I can continue to do so. Thanks for the review!
Reviewer: liveonluna
Date: 01/25/08 19:10
Chapter: Chapter 24 - The Ides of March
This chapter made me smile. I really love this story. SO AWESOME! Except Gavin. GRR. I hope he does something terrible so he can be a bad guy and harry gets to be a hero???? haha. also i love love having ron and hermione back in the story... we needed their friendship again. and besides ron always makes me laugh. especially when he said the curse was anit-climatic. haha. can we see more of their daughter too??anyways..You are such a great author. please, please update soon...=D
Author's Response: You'll just have to wait and see what I do with Gavin. I guarantee it'll be something you won't expect. And yes, I enjoy writing Ron myself. He's a lot like me in the comedic sense, and he's fun to think up lines for.
Little Elina won't play too much of role other than a cute little bundle of joy, but you never know, I might think something up.
Thanks for the compliments and thanks for reading!
Reviewer: Talon_Strike
Date: 01/24/08 21:02
Chapter: Chapter 24 - The Ides of March
I love the story so far, and it's more realistic with what would have happened had Ginny (or any g/f) been kidnapped and so on. BTW, do you post at any other sites? I can't seem to get my stories "right" for MNFF, so I'm over at FF.net..........
Author's Response: Well, I'm glad you're liking the story so far. Hopefully I can keep up the good work.
As for posting at other sites, I've found that FF.net is easiest to upload to, though I only have one story up on it at the moment. ("The Right Man") Everywhere else is just about the same as MNFF, except for the time it takes for approval, which is sometimes longer and sometimes shorter.
As soon as I have 7-Year War done, I'll probably stick it up on a bunch of other sites, like Fictionalley, or Harrypotterfanfiction, but right now I'm concentrating mostly on MNFF.
As always, thanks for reading and thanks for the review!
Reviewer: InsanePottrLvr
Date: 01/20/08 20:35
Chapter: Chapter 24 - The Ides of March
OMG i luv this story it ROCKS!! iam so happy and asd and happy again it is so cool.. please get the next installment fast PLEASE i luv it
thank you
Author's Response: Well, thank you very much for the compliments. The next chapter is already up and awaiting approval. Hopefully you'll like it just as much :P
Reviewer: Dynamite509
Date: 01/19/08 15:18
Chapter: Chapter 24 - The Ides of March
i freakin love this story.
this chapterr is pretty amazingg too with the trio getting back togetherr..
fantastticcc. =]
Author's Response: Well, I'm glad you like it so much. Hopefully I can continue to put out the freaking amazing chapters :) Later!
Reviewer: potterfan48
Date: 01/19/08 0:19
Chapter: Chapter 24 - The Ides of March
"Lucius Malfoy," Gavin wondered.
I found this particular line veyy interesting. I like how you have Harry rebuilding his relationships. I think your story is great. The next few chapters should be fun. One thing I was curious about is in 'Wax on, Wax off" you stated that this chapter gives and indication of the entire story. If there would be an hightened relationship between Essit and Harry. But alas it doesn't appear to be possible.
Author's Response: Actually that line is more a testament to the fact that Gavin really doesn't know much about Harry and Ginny's history. There's nothing too significant about it. But you may have given me an idea for something a little later on.
Hopefully I can continue to satisfy you with where I go in future chapters, since I know I have a few things coming up that a lot of my readers might see as a bit controversial.
The statement about the Wax On, Wax Off chapter...well, at this point I really can't go into detail without going back and reading it again, but I think I meant it as the chapter being a bit of a parallel of the story overall. In the chapter Harry improves his fighting skills and throughout the story, Harry is constantly improving himself overall. Sounds a little corny now that I think about it, but hey, I'm no poet, lol.
And you are correct, I don't plan on any more of a relationship between Essit and Harry other than Mentor/Student. But who knows, maybe I could come up with something for a whole new story.
Thanks for the review and I'll see you next chapter!
Reviewer: oblivious_panda
Date: 01/18/08 0:22
Chapter: Chapter 24 - The Ides of March
dude this story..... is friggen great its the reason i joined this site please if you have a heart write 25 as fast as you can but make it good.... u wouldn't dissapoint a fan now would you?
Author's Response: lol, thanks, I'm glad you like it. The next chapter is already up and awaiting approval, and I hope you like the twist that is incoming.
Thanks for the review and I'll do my best to not disappoint you in future chapters, lol.
Reviewer: Demon Dan34
Date: 01/17/08 16:39
Chapter: Chapter 24 - The Ides of March
Well, Qway. I've read your story as far as it's gone. I've laughed, I've cried, I've gotten a little gassy. I've loved it all around, though. I hope that you continue to update your story and make new ones as time goes on. Keep up the great work!
~Demon Dan34~
Author's Response: Gassy eh? I'll have to add that to my list of emotions that I wanted to bring out of my readers, lol.
The next chapter is already up and awaiting approval and I will continue to upload the next one right after the previous one is approved.
Thanks for the compliments and thanks for reading!
Reviewer: olipop10
Date: 01/17/08 14:19
Chapter: Chapter 24 - The Ides of March
hi Qway, this chapter was really good!
my heart was beating rather fast at the beginning because i was so furious at the weasleys for reacting like that, molly's reaction really shocked me. i had tears in my eyes...and this Gavin guy, i do not like him. could u answer this question please?: does she LOVE gavin?
i'm waiting for the next chapter impatiently!
cheers!
Author's Response: Well, I'm glad I got the reaction out of you that I wanted, when it came to how horrible the Weasley's were being. But don't worry, all should be well soon.
And don't be too hasty with your judgement on Gavin. Just like every other character in the story, he'll have his own personal character flaw, which just might make you change your views on him a bit. I'm trying to do the unexpected here, so hopefully you like where I go with him.
To answer your question: Yes, she does love him. But there's much more to it than that. The next chapter or two should define that love pretty well for you, so hopefully it'll satisfy your curiosity.
Thanks for the review and the next chapter is already awaiting approval :)