Gotta say, i luv that song, but i think u could have done more with the actual fic. I found it a but short, actually.
Nice. And that's such a great song.
Author's Response: thanks! i like positive feedback.
that is sweet, kinda how i picture her acting, not a sobbing baby that doens't get it. she's stronger than that, i like the way you put it. plus, unlike most song fic... i want to go pull out my cd and listen. ;D
Author's Response: yeah...i was a bit tired of all the fics in which Ginny is an emotional wreck, because you know, she's really not. She's a LOT stronger than that--and if u think about it, unless she doesn't trust Harry, she knows he did it out of love 2 protect her. i have another fic that should be published soon, check that out too.
I really like this one-shot it is very beautifully written.
Author's Response: yay! thanks! i really appreciate the feedback, b/c i was never sure if my writing was good--you can't really judge it urself, as u are just SLIGHTLY biased...:D anyhoo, thanks! i really appreciate it...
Author's Response: p.s. i REALLY enjoyed ur story...i wasn't logged in when i read it so i couldn't review... i thought Harry was slightly too emotional for canon, but other than that it's one of my new favorites! update soon, please!!!
aww... thank you for telling me about this! its amazing, and you are an amazing author! wonderful! 10/10
Author's Response: thanks! i don't remember telling u though...no one has ever told me i'm an amazing author...*wipes tear*
I loved it! And I love the song. I saw you had favorited my story, The Epic Tale of the Hogwarts Food-fight, so I decided I'd check out yours. It was wonderful and touching. Great job!
Author's Response: yay! i personally thought that it wasn't that good and their was a fair chance of it getting rejected, so it feels really good for it to touch people. i reallllllly like your story, too. update soon!
hhhhm.... this is the sort of thing that needs a sequel. The ending is like a cliffe at the end of a chapter. But the rest is so sweet. I love his dream where he mutters "I love you Ginny. I love you I love you I love you." It's heart wrenching.
Author's Response: thank you!!! i was thinking about a second chapter instead of a sequal, but i don't know. i have to get some ideas about it first, because it demands something big after the cliffe.
love it! I love that song. It fits perfectly with Harry/Ginny and omg..i just love it.
Author's Response: thanks!
Aw, so sweet! And you write well too. I like the way you made each little section mesh with the words of the song. Good job!
Author's Response: thanks. it took a bit of fiddling but i finally got it!
Aw, so sweet! And you write well too. I like the way you made each little section mesh with the words of the song. Good job!
Yes, that would be ME who wrote the other "Beautiful Disaster" fanfic...so of course I had to read this.
But don't worry, I'm not mad, because you know, I stole the whole idea from ANOTHER fanfic writer. Besides, you did a great job!!
Author's Response: actually--i had the story sitting in my notebook for at least half a year, so i can assure you that i didn't steal that idea from you, and i found the other "beautiful disaster" fic a while AFTER i finished writing this...but thanks for the encouragement. i thought u did well too.
Yes, that would be ME who wrote the other "Beautiful Disaster" fanfic...so of course I had to read this.
But don't worry, I'm not mad, because you know, I stole the whole idea from ANOTHER fanfic writer. Besides, you did a great job!!
ooh, this is so cute. I loved ti.
Author's Response: thanks!
very nicely done! I love Kelly Clarkson and always thought this song fitted with Harry and Ginny! Good Job, 10/10
Author's Response: thanks...i really appreciate your review. What would u think about a sequal/epilogue?? i don't know, i kind of like the enigma around it without a definite ending...
I think it's a nice piece of writing. I like the way you put the song into the story and how nicely the lyrics were connected to Ginny's feelings as well. There were a few typos though, i think. Anyway, enough of the rambling. Great job, keep going!
Author's Response: thanks...it's kind of odd having people reading your writing...you feel a bit watched. i read your dream wedding story a while back and really liked that one. yeah, i did notice some typos...oh well. i thought it was ok for my first-ever attempt. thanks for the support!
I like it so far. how you mixed the song in with the chapter. berry good.
Author's Response: thanks! when i heard the song i thought it would fit pretty well...I'm really glad you enjoyed it!
so sad! but so sweet!! and so good! im gonna cry...
Author's Response: thanks a lot! i actually didn't think it was that emotion inspiring, but hey, i'm glad you think it's good! thanks for reading it!
Author's Response: p.s. i saw u were a beta when i looked up your name, and that u had a story. you said u had x number of reads. how do u find that out???
