That was a very interesting way of looking at the course of events when James and Lily died. I would never have thought for Lily to cast a spell on Harry to protect him or for Voldemort to give Harry his scar intentionally. All in all, a very good story.
I like how you did Lily and James' death from an owl's point of view, I don't think I've seen it done before. It was interesting how you came up with spells and magically enhanced objects to provide solutions for the different facts we know to be true. Like the "Amor Contego" and the crib that flipped over when Harry began crying. Very interesting.
My favourite part was how Athena liked Edwin. It just seems kind of ironic to me that James' likes Lily, and Lily's owl likes James' owl. Keep up the fantastic writing!