omg. loved it but still! tonkzie ;)
you're fics are always so sad but so touching!
Wow. Very intense. I'm a big Remus'Tonks fan, so it's not my favorite story, but it's still good. Very well-written. Nice job!
Aww! This is so good! Great job!
If she really loves him, she will wait... no matter how long it takes. It just can't end like that! And maybe i'm a total hypocrite for sending this review after writing Resolute but... THIS IS REMUS AND TONKS, NOT HARRY AND GINNY! (for the record, the story was well-written, but...)
Wonderfully depressing (meant as a compliment, for the record.)
Are you just trying to make me cry?? Gosh, why did you have to be such an awesome writer??? Please don't mind my insane-ness... That really was great, I really loved it :)
great! great story i hope it have a sequence for this and i hope they can be together!!! lol
This is really good, and SO sad!
THIS IS REALLY GOOD. IT IS PRETTY SAD BUT I LOVED IT. WRITE MORE!!!
ouch...:( You've created powerful image here, and in a way I'm kind of glad that they didn't end up together. I love the idea of Tonks + Remus scratched into the wood as well...A really well written one-shot. I'll check out the song too!
What?! Please enlighten me.
Oh my gosh... that's so sad! My throat got all choked up. Poor Remus! :(
That was incredibly depressing...just like the Sweetest Sin...so sad. Tonks shouldn'ta done that. She wouldn't. Oh man..
Awww! That was so SAD!! Why?! Why?!!??! poor remus. why bill. and what's with the Fler thing. he didnt have an affair did he? Why?!? why, Remus WHYYY?!?!! *runns off crying*
Wow! Talk about a dark one... about a man living with the worst mistake he ever made... Remus may as well go dig his grave! I hope JKR gives him some happiness at the end of the books, that she let's him open his heart; you've certainly illustrated what's in store for him if he doesn't.
that was sooo sad...i agree with starmaiden and petiteloupegarou,she did say at the end of book 6 that she doesen't care and that she loves him...if she really does...she will wait until remus accepts her...no matter how long
yeah, i was just thinking- if tonks really loved remus that much, she would have kept bugging him about it, would have kept trying to get through to him- she wouldn't have just settled down with bill- especially since he still misses fleur- that's just not the kind of person tonks is. At least that's how i see her.
Weird, but excellently written. I also don't quite get why the phone is there, but I suppose it's artistic license for the benefit of the story.
I am not sure exactly what to feel about this. On one hand, half of me is screaming, "NO!! It can't be like that!" but the other half points out that Remus tried to make it like that. I suppose the only thing I wonder about is Remus changed his mind about loving her? Or did he simply grow bitter because he couldn't have her? That's the only thing I would ask. In any case, this is very, very well done and a great addition to the needy Remus/Tonks section!