MuggleNet Fan Fiction
Harry Potter stories written by fans!
Reviews For One Good Day

Name: Diamond Quill (Signed) · Date: 10/29/06 12:28 · For: Chapter 5: Fireside and Moonlight
I have a confession. I've read not only this fic without leaving a review, but also Everybody Does It and Right Here. In my defence, the reason isn't chronic laziness (though that is a part of it) but also being very very busy and as you probably gathered from my review in Shadows I like to be able to leave decent reviews. It's just the matter of having enough time. So I'm sorry for not R/R-ing but I haven't had the time and now I'm finally getting round to it!

As you have said in nearly all your responses that you like this story the least, it was with some trepidation that I actually started reading it. I admit that, at first, I was slightly disappointed. The story wasn't bad by any means, but it lacked a bit of the sparkle that Shadows had which marked it out as better than the rest. However I continued reading, partly because I was interested to see how you would end Harry's Good Day and partly because I am an obsessive R/Hr H/G fan and like fics which have both pairings.

Then I got to chapter 5 and my feelings changed completely. I now understand why you wrote the rest of the story the way you did and I agree with it 100%. I love the way you intertwined the two couples' stories and switched between the two so easily.

The talk between Ron and Hermione is dialogue written at its best and although I thought that it was a little bit drawn out, I really enjoyed the argument between Harry and Ginny too. I found the bit when Harry was listing all the people he loved very moving.

The final paragraph works really well too and you end the whole thing off nicely with the repetion of the title. All in all, very, very good. So sorry again for the delay in reviewing and I promise I will review the other two asap- I adored Right Here.

Well Done and keep writing,x~Diamond Quill~x

Author's Response: No apologies are needed, though I do hope you do get a chance to review the other two stories as well. And I truly appreciate the review.

Also, I'm sure you have noticed that I like to put some time and such in my responses, so anyway, here we go. Yeah, I make it pretty obvious that I like this story the least, and it's because of the meandering fluffiness of the first four chapters. To be honest I think that was just an excercize in characterization more than anything, you know, trying to anticipate how these characters would act in such and such a situation. The other part of the first four chapters was totally about me catering to a certain audience, and I don't know. And then yeah, there's chapter five, and I really liked writing that, and you'll notice that I continue to go back to that over and over again. I think with both scenes... Well, I used to beta read and such and before I got so engrossed in my own writing I used to read other stories, and two things I would see an awful lot are proposals and gifts. Like, I would read a scene where Harry proposes to Ginny,and as I read it I would tick off things that I would think were "wrong" in my head. And the gifts, like for christmas and birthdays, and it's just I think the whole scene started off with just wanting to do a very real or what seemed to me to be a real touching wedding proposal and showing a very real gift giving instance. What I loved about the locket is that I still get usage out of that now in epilogues part II. Okay, rambling now, and I should probably put this response out of its misery now. Thank you for the review and can't wait for the rest.

Name: Krissa (Signed) · Date: 10/21/06 18:34 · For: Chapter 5: Fireside and Moonlight
Oh and btw, I only read this last chapter, so I had the impression of a one-shot, which works just as good:)

Author's Response: I think for any other story I would have been offended, but for this one, I'm almost appreciative as this chapter is obviously more important than the rest. This is not only the chapter with content and substance, but it's also the chapter to which allude in other stories.

Name: Krissa (Signed) · Date: 10/21/06 18:32 · For: Chapter 5: Fireside and Moonlight
I like it. I like how Hermione refuses but Ron makes her understand, I like how Harry and Ginny has this kind of understanding eachother all the time, and I like those little moments where everything is good before the war begins.

Author's Response: Wrote a long review, got timed out, uber pissed about it. summation: Thank you, and I just realized that I pulled a lot of this story from military experiences, and those days before you have to go away, and how they change into something different as the hours to departure tick away.

Name: mrskimberleyweasley (Signed) · Date: 10/20/06 17:06 · For: Chapter 5: Fireside and Moonlight
I actually did cry at this story. I'm not even joking its so sweet. If Harry doesn't come back for a lifetime of good days, then i might have to track you down...
And if Ron and Hermione don't get married and produce hundreds of tiny little ginger children, i will track you down even sooner...
I actually think you are a genius.
Kim xxxxx

Author's Response: YAY! I'm almost to the point where I cheer when I make people cry. I love it. Really, I love writing emotionally, and I love it more when those emotions carry over enough to induce tears. Thank you so much for that. As for you tracking me down... I'm pretty much toast I think...

Name: Wileycat (Signed) · Date: 10/18/06 8:11 · For: Chapter 5: Fireside and Moonlight
this was a very good story definitely one of my favorites. Can't wait to read the others.

Author's Response: Thank you so much. It's the least favorite of mine that I've written, really. So Iguess that means I can't wait until you read the others also.

Name: beautiful banshee (Signed) · Date: 10/02/06 8:54 · For: Chapter 5: Fireside and Moonlight
You have a wonderful writing style that I believe many others lack. While like any other female I enjoy the soppy relationship stuff it was great to see the subtle character developments you made for each and every one of our heroes. Well done on this fic, I will certainly be looking the others up, if only to see whether they reach my expectations!

Author's Response: OH wow, thank you ever so much for the review. I'm glad you enjoyed this story, and I gotta tell you, I really can't wait for you to read what's yet to come as I see this as my worst story in fanfiction. Thank you again, and hope to hear from you later.

Name: Igo Retla (Signed) · Date: 09/23/06 13:21 · For: Chapter 5: Fireside and Moonlight
Well written, thank you!

Author's Response: Thank you. Not my favorite of mine, no, but people continue to love it. Thanks.

Name: Liadian Weasley (Signed) · Date: 09/20/06 15:43 · For: Chapter 5: Fireside and Moonlight
That was definantly a great chapter. You threw me a curve ball at the end, totally unexpected. But thats what makes it great. I am such a Hr/R fan so that scene of the proposal had me in tears, than theres a double wamie with H/G on the love issue....pretty intence. What can I say, you had me glued to my computer. I cant wait to read your next stories.

Author's Response: And I seriously can't wait until you've read them. Especially if you're an Hr/R fan. For the most part I follow the progression of H/G, but I have a couple more R/Hr scenes up my sleeve, and I really can't wait for your response to those. Thank you ever so much for reading my stories. What's even better is that these two are just more like prologues. The Epilogues are the main event (sort of. In truth, the Epilogues are a kind of prologue to another story, but that's all besides the point). Well, I hope you love the rest. Man, september's been a great month for me, lots of reviews, getting back in the saddle for Part II of epilogues, and even a few nominations in the quicksilver quills thingy. Rock on.

Name: Helios (Signed) · Date: 09/19/06 18:36 · For: Chapter 5: Fireside and Moonlight
okay...best story EVER!! laffed my ass off...balled my eyes out...perfect combination :) awesomeness

Author's Response: THANK YOU!!! Man, if this story got a reaction out of you, can't wait until you read the rest. This is by far my least favorite story. Thanks for the read, and hope to see you again.

Name: Bucky Catt (Signed) · Date: 09/06/06 20:06 · For: Chapter 5: Fireside and Moonlight
I can hardly see the keyboard through the tears! Such a beautiful, sad, and happy story. Wonderful writing!!!

Author's Response: Thank you very much. Truth be told this is my least favorite of the stories I've written and still it is able to obtain such an awesome response from you, thank you. I really hope you'll read the rest of my stories as I think they're all better than this one, and even better are all in the same storyline, thank you so much.

Name: Kay Loves You All (Signed) · Date: 09/04/06 16:46 · For: Chapter 5: Fireside and Moonlight
Just one word for this story. Or here are the top ten

10. Rad
9. Awesome
8. Pwnful
7. Lovely
6. Pulchritudious
5. Great
4. Super
2. Lubb

Author's Response: 10. Thanks 9. Danke 8. Arigoto 7. shi shi 6. gracias 5. graci 4. merci 3. domo 2. THX 1. SUPER AWESOMELY THANK YOU FOR THE REVIEW!

Name: tljokerst (Signed) · Date: 09/02/06 18:53 · For: Chapter 5: Fireside and Moonlight
really good story

Author's Response: thanks very much.

Name: sarah 185 (Signed) · Date: 09/01/06 14:19 · For: Chapter 5: Fireside and Moonlight
Firstly,let me say wow!! I am amazed at the quality of all the stories in mnff,and also this is my first review,so cut me some slack! I think that the last chapter was the most satisfying to read,as you conveyed the emotions in the last few paragraphs between Harry and Ginny so well i am shocked,and extremely jelous as i could never write like that if Jo Rowling was sat beside me telling me what to write!
I wanted to include a critisism in all of my adoration for you writer types,but I dont think I could find one in this paricular story,so that will have to be my only problem,its TOO good.I also feel that if you were to develope your iwn characters in another story then you would be a VERY successful author.I'm going to stop it there or I will find myself rambling and not go to bed tonight.WELL DONE i think you have done Harry proud!!

Author's Response: Thank you so much. Admittedly, this is my least favorite story I've written, but I'm still fond of it. It definitely gave me a chance to take the characters to another level. So one thing I can say is that if you enjoyed this, i would really encourage you to read the rest of my stories. As for your one criticism.. Um, thanks for that? Definitely not the harshest criticism I've ever had.

Name: Adelfore Flamell (Signed) · Date: 08/29/06 1:31 · For: Chapter 4: Kisses In The Dark
awesome... for a guy that doesnt write much fluf, you sure got a handle on it! Great stuff!!

Author's Response: whew all caught up on the reviews for this story. Thanks for reading it, and I appreciate all the great reviews.

Name: Adelfore Flamell (Signed) · Date: 08/29/06 1:25 · For: Chapter 5: Fireside and Moonlight
how could anyone possibly leave a bad review after this...?

That was by far the single best ending to any fic i have read on MNFF so far. There have been many. But none even come CLOSE to that. It was epic. It was unimaginable. Writers like you are the inspiration for beginners like me. You are the second author i've read that makes me want to give up my own writing... not out of shame that i couldn't write something as good...but because i just get so much power and love and emotion out of out of reading stories like this. I almost feel like i get more out of stories from others then from myown. I cant begin to thank you for writing a sequel and i cant wait to start reading it. Please please write more!!! Absolutely phenomenal!!!!!

Author's Response: Man I love it when people do what you have done, and I get to read the reactions after each chapter and then I get this. the first four chapters are usually something quick and nice, and I appreciate it, but I put so much heart into the last half of this last chapter, and when I get reviews like this, well, it makes it seem worth it. Thank you so much for everything. While I have said many times this is the least favorite of my fics, the ending is something I'm quite proud of. And don't stop writing PLEASE! There is a lot you can do to develop yourself as a writer but the single biggest thing you can do is just to keep writing, find and hone your voice, and one day you can be like me and write fanfics that get awesome reviews like this one (note: this last little bit was written kind of tongue in cheek. I don't really think that highly of myself). Thanks for the wonderful reviews and can't wait to read more from you.

Name: Adelfore Flamell (Signed) · Date: 08/29/06 0:17 · For: Chapter 4: Kisses In The Dark
awesome... for a guy that doesnt write much fluf, you sure got a handle on it! Great stuff!!

Author's Response: Thank you. Okay, I like fluff. A little fluff. It sure is fun to write when you're a big softy like me.

Name: Adelfore Flamell (Signed) · Date: 08/28/06 23:57 · For: Chapter 3: The Strip
love this story... its so imaginative, and yet so perfect at the same time! It fits them so well!

Author's Response: Thank you. I think with this story it was a big experiment just to see if you know they kids would get to be just kids if all the other crap in their life was taken out.

Name: Adelfore Flamell (Signed) · Date: 08/28/06 23:48 · For: Chapter 2: Eggs And Soda
well i do believe it is, but i dont think as much as cola or anything like that. (great story...im lovin it!)

Author's Response: hehehe... i'm lovin it... nice product placement there. Yeah, see, no one seems to know for sure if butterbeer is carbonated or not. Really would suck for me if it was.

Name: Adelfore Flamell (Signed) · Date: 08/28/06 23:38 · For: Chapter 1: Just Harry
this is awesome. Well done!! Cant wait to read on.

Author's Response: Thank you so much, can't wait to read the rest of your reviews.

Name: staggering (Signed) · Date: 08/28/06 1:52 · For: Chapter 2: Eggs And Soda
I'm pretty sure butter beer isn't carbonated. Still love the story.

Author's Response: Thank you. yeah, it was on another site where I ran into someone who would disagree with the both of us, so I just put in the disclaimer. One of these days when I'm rich and famous and writing continuation books in the HP universe, I'll be sure to ask JKR whether it is or isn't. Thanks for the review.

You must login (register) to review.