Reviewer: PadfootBaby
Date: 06/17/06 11:22
Chapter: Dumbledore's Favourite Girl

Interesting... Very interesting...

Reviewer: bookworm2011
Date: 06/13/06 11:53
Chapter: Dumbledore's Favourite Girl

I like it!No I don't like it! I LOVE IT!!!

Reviewer: Masked One
Date: 06/05/06 22:30
Chapter: Dumbledore's Favourite Girl

And then, a whisper, a sharp breathe of a voice… “Minerva.” This is where the marvelous creepiness of this story really sets in - and with great effect. And it just gets creepier from there on out. I’m really not sure what’s more disturbing; the implied Minerva/Dumbledore, or the strange lure of the Minerva/Tom.

If there’s a problem with this story, I think the opening might be a bit longer than necessary. There’s some very nice description there, but it’s a bit superfluous to the rest. It feels a bit like padding. It does set the stage, though, preparing the reader to shiver when Tom is introduced.

Your characterizations are simply perfect. Tom, and how poorly he deals with even that relatively small rejection. Minerva, and her slight hero-worship of Dumbledore. I see the older Minerva perfectly in her. You deliberately leave a lot of questions here. What is going on between Minerva and Dumbledore? Something, clearly, if only attraction. What is the history between Tom and Minerva? Does Tom seek some sort of revenge, either in his school days or later?

This is one of my favorite creepy stories; I’ve read it before, and now I’m going to make a note to read it again.

Reviewer: I Love Severus Snape
Date: 04/29/06 16:40
Chapter: Dumbledore's Favourite Girl

*Squees because she finally found her OTP and because this is completely brilliant.* Minerva and Tom were both so perfectly in character... I could truly see Jo writing the younger versions of them that way. The encounter is far from casual; they both know what the other wants, and you can tell from their actions. The ending has a lovely finality to it, which I also like. Great job... I love it!

Reviewer: Ravenclaw_5th_Year
Date: 04/20/06 19:36
Chapter: Dumbledore's Favourite Girl

Extremely interesting, and very well thought out (or so it seems)! You're the first i'm going to give a 10/10!

Reviewer: Periwinkle
Date: 04/14/06 18:17
Chapter: Dumbledore's Favourite Girl

Very interesting. I like how you kept them both IC, and your vivid descriptions kept me reading until the end.

[i]The winter night was colder and darker than most. Eerie patterns of frost crawled across the glass window panes that reflected the black hours of the morning, as a draught crept through the corridors, chilling the castle’s inhabitants and creeping into their unconscious thoughts.[/i]

I really liked this sentence. It drew me into this story; kept me wanting to read more.

[i]“Yes, Tom. That is all.”[/i]

I also liked this sentence. It gives a certain finality, and satisfaction. Splendid job!

Reviewer: QueenHal
Date: 04/02/06 22:46
Chapter: Dumbledore's Favourite Girl

This is such a little slice of goodness. Or badness. But the good kind of badness. What I mean is, I love it down to the last striking exchange between such an unthinkable pair of characters. One-- young, quick witted, and righteous, the other-- dark, devious, and plotting. And the moment they come together, it's just like candy.

I really admire how you turn Minerva's character around. When we first see her, she seems meek and naïve, a mere child who could hold no power over someone like Tom Riddle. But when she delivers that last biting line to him at the end, I feel like swooping her up and kissing her on the forehead—though can you imagine how she would love that!? Hah! In many ways, she reminds me of Hermione. Lines like “I am not prowling,” Minerva proclaimed in her defence. “I was restless, I thought I’d go for a small stroll…” are very reminiscent of something Hermione would say. However, there's something new, something more, [is dangerous the right word?] about her. I adore it.

You have me a little confused, though, with your italicized sentences, because they all seem to be italicized for different reasons. The first, [- are you doing up at this hour?”] seems to be a sentence she's finishing in her head. And while I like this, I don't think it's necessary. However, if you really want it in there, I suggest you do something like:

--are you doing up at this hour? The words never reached her lips as she blinked at the dark haired boy...

The second italicized bit looks as if she's having a bit of deja vu. Why is this familiar? Is this what she feels when she's with Dumbledore....?

Then, the third: He plays games with people’s minds and hearts, and he wins. I can't decide whether this is something she's thinking, or whether this is something she remembers Dumbledore saying about him. I want you to connect this, because I have a feeling if it's clarified it will make this story even more powerful than it already is.

Love, love, love. Wonderful one-shot, Jen.

Reviewer: HermioneDancr
Date: 02/14/06 16:09
Chapter: Dumbledore's Favourite Girl

Lovely story, Jenna. It could be smoothed out a bit, but very nicely written. And wonderful emotional interplay (don't you dare read that the wrong way) too.

And since I never looked it over for you... “I’m sure all of Hogwarts knows how the Gryffindor prefect won favour with her Head of House,” he said icily Dumbledore’s favourite girl, aren’t you, Minerva?” You're missing a period and quotation marks between icily and Dumbledore.

:: huggles ::

I hope you know you're marvelous.

Reviewer: Midnight Tragedy
Date: 02/13/06 22:36
Chapter: Dumbledore's Favourite Girl

That was beautiful. I'm afraid I can't see Minerva kissing anyone, let alone someone as evil as Tom, but everyone must have been young once eh? 10/10

You must login (register) to review.
Find out everything you need to know about the site right here.

We have stories and authors in this archive.


Choose Theme:
Epithalamium by Squibstress Professors
Minerva McGonagall is a bright, talented witch with dreams of becoming the first...
A Seer Named Rosemary Snape by PlutoLovegood 3rd-5th Years
In 2018 Neville and Harry deliver a Hogwarts acceptance letter to Rosemary Snape...
Through The Storm- The End Was Just The Beginning by HarryJamesPotter10 6th-7th Years
This story picks up where the books left off, mostly canon, and it follows almost...
whimper by psijupiter 6th-7th Years
I play to my strengths. As do we all. In the midst of the first wizarding...
Over A Mug of Tea by hestiajones 1st-2nd Years
I think of her as a sister. The words rang clearly, loudly in his mind. I...
Gaps Between by lucca4 6th-7th Years
Falling in love teaches Dennis Creevey that sometimes, needing someone isn't...
To Fear the Flame by Acacia Carter 3rd-5th Years
Neville hadn't expected his boggart to ever change. Perhaps he should have done.
Good King Ragnuk by Oregonian 1st-2nd Years
Ragnuk, King of the Goblins and master silversmith, forged a sword for Godric...