Reviews For Why Potter?
Reviewer: i love prongs
Date: 06/04/06 12:14
Chapter: Confusion

no no no james potter and sophie snow why oh why oh why? i dot like sophie she could stop all progress betweeen lily and james but i do want to know about her big secret though please p date soon good chapter

chelsea xxx

Author's Response: Mmmh, they don't necessarily have to get together, do they? *feel slightly devilish* I'll try to finish chapter six soon, and I'll love any suggestions anyone has for me!

Reviewer: A Excess of Phlegm
Date: 06/03/06 23:26
Chapter: Confusion

oh yeah, i forgot. is sophie snow the black haired girl? the one that remus was watching, and the one that went into their compartment at the beginning?

Author's Response: That's the one! I just made her into a real character with an actual name this time.

Reviewer: A Excess of Phlegm
Date: 06/03/06 23:23
Chapter: Confusion

wait a sec, am i missing something??????? who was the girl watching them, did i just skip over it??????? i dont think i did because i read it through twice. i was all worked up about it!!!!!!!!!!!!! could you please tell me whats going on? you promised to tell us!!!!!!! but other than that, 10/10! update soon!

Author's Response: You got it on the second review, I believe. Sophie Snow is definitely a main suspect. Thanks for the awesome review!

Reviewer: lovegoodfan
Date: 06/01/06 12:33
Chapter: Interruptions

you need to update soon. otherwise its good.

Author's Response: Thank you! Chapter five is in queue since last Thursday, hopefully it gets posted soon. *crosses fingers extremely hard*

Reviewer: HPandDRfreak
Date: 05/07/06 22:36
Chapter: Interruptions


1) i am really interested in who the girl is
2) i am interested in reading more period
3) i LOVE that u used a larger vocabulary (unbeknownst)
4) i liked the way u showed sirius and remus THEN lily and james

i'm sorry but, BAD POINTS:

1) still finding spelling/grammatical errors
2) ummmmm.... i had one but i 4got, if i remember i'll tell u

Author's Response: Thanks for all those good points! And thanks for the bad points, too, I'll be sure to check and re-check the spelling and grmmar in my computer before I submit chapter five, which is almost done! Thank you!

Reviewer: HPandDRfreak
Date: 04/21/06 16:39
Chapter: Doubt

wow....good chapter..... probably my favorite so far..... keep up the good work!

Author's Response: That means a lot, since I wasn't really happy with this chapter... so thanks!

Reviewer: HPandDRfreak
Date: 04/21/06 13:17
Chapter: Rejected

ok, i found quite a few grammatical errors, but still good,

Author's Response: Really? I'll check it out again and see if I can spot any. Thanks for pointitng it out!

Reviewer: HPdiva
Date: 04/18/06 17:35
Chapter: Interruptions

OK,OK,OK I've narrowed it down to three suspects (lol) Lily, her two friends or the mysterious girl that walked in on the marauders in their compartment. I'm leaning towards the 'mysterious girl' though because in the story she seems to be listening in alot..hmmm, makes me wonder what she has to do with the plot and if she's going to become close with Lily or the Marauders or perhaps the dark side. Like i said in my other review..I love the chapter and I can't wait for you to update! your update will reveal the true identity perhaps?maybe?maybe not?..anywhoo, please update soon ~xoxo~

Author's Response: Great suspects, I must say. And yes, it's one of those. And I actually did keep you thinking! That is so great! Yes, she does have to do with the plot, a lot. I'll give you that since you gave so much thought to it. Thanks!

Reviewer: HPdiva
Date: 04/18/06 17:20
Chapter: Interruptions

Honestly, I can't think of who the girl could be...mmm, but you have me thinking! Please update soon though, its theleast you could do after leaving us all on a cliffie~xoxo

Author's Response: I'm trying, I'm trying! I'll try to finish it by tomorrow ot Thursday, I promise I'll try. Key word there: trying. I'm so glad I kept you thinking about it!

Reviewer: pedrola black
Date: 04/14/06 13:56
Chapter: Rejected

JaneA i'm your biggest fan. i'm your #1 fan i love your writing. i think your going to be an awesome writer one day. your so cool. your to good to be true.
your admirer

Author's Response: wow...thanks, I'm flattered. I'm glad you like my fic so much, this is one of my best reviews. Hopefully you'll like my next update as much. Thanks so much! --JaneA

Reviewer: heartachin4harry
Date: 04/14/06 9:36
Chapter: Interruptions

This is great! I really want to know who that girl is! Must you leave it at a cliffie?! Update soon!

Author's Response: It was just such a great place to leave it at! I'll try to update soon, though I think I'm nearing a writer's block... It'll come out eventually, hopefully in the next week... Thanks so much for the review!

Reviewer: Quiditch fan
Date: 04/09/06 18:31
Chapter: Interruptions

i thin kin the last line it is supposed to say "thoughtfully" not "thoughfully" and i believe the girl is lily....not the mysterious black haired girl. and i am still trying to she good...or bad. hmmmmm, much to ponder. anyway, update soon. this was a great chapter! oh yeah, i liked hw she didn't say yes or no. very good. very clever.

Author's Response: omg, I loved this review! So many details! And yeah, thank you for pointing out that typo, I'll fix it as soon as I can, when I can edit again! And you're the only person who's said that it can be lily, and not the other girl! I think I will actually write a lot today, and try to finish chapter five, since I loved this review so much!

Reviewer: xcxcharlottexcx
Date: 04/06/06 17:20
Chapter: Interruptions

Who is that girl?? I loved this chapter. *****10/10*****

Author's Response: Thanks! I thought people wouldn't like this chapter, actually, so thanks so much!!!!! As to your question... I can't really answer it, since I would be giving away the story and everything...

Reviewer: A Excess of Phlegm
Date: 04/04/06 18:14
Chapter: Interruptions

its has to be that one girl, ya know the one with the hair, and the blue eyes. (i guess i should say black hair). well it is really good, i liked this chapter alot!

Author's Response: Thanks! Is it the girl with the black hair? Good guess, that's all I have to say for now...

Reviewer: Rae_of_sunshine
Date: 04/04/06 15:29
Chapter: Interruptions

really enjoyed it :-D Who is that girl? *ponders* yay - keep writing and i'll be back to see if you update!

Author's Response: Thanks! Who is that girl? I suppose you'll find out next chapter! I'll try to finish it as soon as I can!

Reviewer: KaNsAs_Cutie_2011
Date: 03/30/06 16:21
Chapter: Doubt

omg i love ur story please o please update soon

Author's Response: Thank you so much! Chapter four is, as of yesterday (3/29), in queue!

Reviewer: lubug
Date: 03/18/06 9:39
Chapter: Doubt

ok... maybe your right.... poor james! *snif, snif* p.s. if you have NO idea what im talking about read the authors note after my last review

Author's Response: Exactly. I feel the same way. Poor James. But I'm telling you, you'll be surprised. I suggest you look in chapter 1, otherwise you won't recognize someone. Unless I specifize (I forgot how to spell that). Hmm.

Reviewer: xcxcharlottexcx
Date: 03/16/06 11:56
Chapter: Doubt

woops i meant longer not monger.

Author's Response: That's ok, I knew what you meant. :)

Reviewer: xcxcharlottexcx
Date: 03/16/06 11:55
Chapter: Doubt

Luv the story so far. I wish your chapterswere slightly monger though HINT HINT *****10/10*****

Author's Response: Awesome! Thanks! I AM trying to make chapter four at least a little longer, which is why it might take some more time than usual to get it up. Thanks for reviewing!

Reviewer: Quiditch fan
Date: 03/11/06 10:38
Chapter: Doubt

woooooo, i just read your response! i am such a great reviewer!!!!! (my head swells up because i have such a big ego) woooooo, i am giving good suggestions! thanks, your response made my day.

Author's Response: Haha, lol. No problem, though I'm still not sure what I'll do. I'm in a huge internal debate. Seriously, I'm thinking of making a pro and con list of Lily saying yes. Or no. Well, I guess you'll find out next chapter! :D

You must login (register) to review.
Find out everything you need to know about the site right here.

We have stories and authors in this archive.


Choose Theme:
Epithalamium by Squibstress Professors
Minerva McGonagall is a bright, talented witch with dreams of becoming the first...
A Ship to Wreck by FloreatCastellum 6th-7th Years
And good God, under starry skies we are lostAnd into the breach we got tossedAnd...
The Apothecary and the Bane by Icarus Unbound 1st-2nd Years
The apothecary receives a visitor in the wizarding slums of London.
Twilit Confessions by ahattab33 3rd-5th Years
After returning from Australia with the Grangers, Ron realises the moment to...
Soul Sister by hestiajones 1st-2nd Years
Ted and Andromeda have just eloped. So, they dance. A songfic featuring...
Time and Tide by minnabird 6th-7th Years
Filius has seen her all his life: the Woman. She has been drifting through time...
Footprints in the Sand by Equinox Chick 6th-7th Years
It was a summer like any other for Danny. He worked at his parents' Bed and...
Consolation by Gmariam 3rd-5th Years
For years, Remus Lupin found comfort in the arms of Rosmerta Richardson...until...
Dangerous Liaisons by eternalangel 6th-7th Years
It was a dangerous game she was playing; Dorcas Meadowes knew it, but the exhilaration...