MuggleNet Fan Fiction
Harry Potter stories written by fans!
Reviews For I'll Fight For You

Name: pheonixfeather94 (Signed) · Date: 02/29/08 18:51 · For: Prologue
OMG THIS STORY IS AMAZING!!!!!!!! One problem tho...ITS NOT YOURS!!! I cannot believe that someone would sink so low as to copy someone else's work. That's just...horrible. I know from experience that plagurism hurts and I would advise you to stop now before the mods find out. Then you'll be in really big trouble...

Name: hplover45 (Signed) · Date: 07/16/07 23:12 · For: The Dreadful News
so confusing

Name: WunderWitch (Signed) · Date: 02/05/07 19:34 · For: Where is Hope?

Name: fairekisssed (Signed) · Date: 11/24/06 17:01 · For: Prologue

Name: witchwriter113 (Signed) · Date: 06/11/06 15:03 · For: The Dreadful News




Name: FanFicFanatic12 (Signed) · Date: 05/06/06 18:52 · For: The Dreadful News
I just realized I haven't reviewed your story yet--my account just started working.

I absolutly love your story--I put it on my favorites list. Please update soon, though! I've been waiting. :-)

Name: Potterfantic913 (Signed) · Date: 12/29/05 19:27 · For: The Dreadful News
Why you little son of a monkey. How dare you steal someones story. Why would you? Is it because you have nothing else to do in your small pathetic life? What is wrong with you? And you call yourselve a Harry Potter fan. You make me sick. All readers go read the story by the REAL author. Link: http://boards.harrypotter.warnerbros.com/web/thread.jspa?messageID=2023922924� Did you REALLY think that you will get away with this? Go make your own story you leech. I HOPE YOU GET BANNED!!!!

Name: deafening silence (Signed) · Date: 12/29/05 19:24 · For: The Dreadful News
Listen, winternights, I don't know who you are, but I really think you should stop. This is, quite obviously, plagerism of the fanfiction written by summerskies on harrypotter.com; it was forced to move to a new thread back in August, by which time summer had written quite a bit and become pretty popular (with those who read it at the very least.) Unless I'm mistaken, you started writing in December It's exactly the same, except for the fact that three chapters are missing, and the ones you do have up are out of order. As both a writer and a reviewer, I must plead with you to stop this before it becomes too out of control. I read it at harrypotter.com, and the readers there aren't too happy with you. You've already met some, I see, and, trust me, the others are just as angry. Please consider my request. I hope that soon you will get the inspiration to write something of your own, and if that happens, I wish best of luck to you. Just remember: no one likes a plagerizer.

Name: HorcruxesHunter7 (Signed) · Date: 12/29/05 18:44 · For: The Dreadful News
YOU SHOULD BE ASHAMED OF YOURSELF! I cannot believe that you would go so low as to copy SUMMER'S STORY! Its hers and your a plain JERK to copy it THEN insult her by calling her a FRAUD! YOUR THE FRAUD SO GIVE UP THE ACT! TO ALL OF THE READERS HERE: go to the official harry potter website and the real story is there! it'll most likely be on the top of the fan fiction pages because itsone of the best ones out there! I AM APPALLED THAT YOU WOULD DO SUCH A HORRIBLE THING! THIS STORY IS GREAT AND THE REAL AUTHOR SHOULD GET THE CREDIT!

Name: lily_loves_james (Signed) · Date: 12/29/05 16:24 · For: The Dreadful News
Okay, okay this is just cruel! Whoever you are winternights, that is just horrible! How you could steal Summer's story and then LIE about it and pretend you never did it? Any who is reading this, do NOT listen to winternights! She's the fraud! She stole Summer's story because she was just plain jealous! I'm serious, I never thought someone could get so low. It's awful. You should be ashamed winternights! And if you're a bumper on Summer's story on harrypotter.com, I suggest you just leave because when Summer find out who you are, you'll be in so much trouble - Suzy

Name: Tinn Tam (Signed) · Date: 12/29/05 14:50 · For: The Dreadful News
Now, this is weird. I went to that link... just to check out... and there actually IS the very same story. Only much longer. I don't know what to believe (though I don't think insults are totally appropriate)(but that's really the only opinion I'll give here). I'll wait to see what happens next. Still, I can't see why someone would copy someone else's story: what's the point? Getting good reviews? Whereas it's not even their own work? Not gratifying, is it? Come on, this is ridiculous. I'm really sorry something like that happened. I love this story.

Name: summerskies (Signed) · Date: 12/29/05 11:33 · For: The Dreadful News
I can't believe I'm being accused of fraud. You want to know what day I started writing this story, Nov. 13 2004 on the Warner Brothers Boards. The thread was deleted and on Aug. 4 2005 I reposted it here: http://boards.harrypotter.warnerbros.com/web/thread.jspa?threadID=2000436012&start=3465&tstart=0. I'm 113, 773 words into it and on chapter 17. The first three chapters, which proves that this wanna be doesn't know what she's doing, were cut out. They can be found here: http://www.fanfictionworld.net/hparchive/viewuser.php?uid=41491. I will be e-mailing the mods about this once they get back from their break because I think that plagiarism of any kind should not go on like this. I hope this parasite doesn't latch onto any other authors because she has no brain of her own and blatantly flaunts this. -Summerskies, the author.

Name: mmm_bacon (Signed) · Date: 12/29/05 11:19 · For: The Dreadful News
hi I'd just like to say summer, good going and to the fake author SHE IS NOT A FRAUD!!! and to the readers listen to summer her story has been up on the hp boards for a while and the reason you are all so confused is because this 'author' has left out three chapters! -JB

Name: summerskies (Signed) · Date: 12/27/05 10:13 · For: Where is Hope?
OMG THIS STORY ISSSSSSSS SOOOOOOO AWESOME. But maybe the reason why your readers are so confused is because you cut out the first three chapters and you don't really know what's going on in the story because you didn't write it. I wrote it. This is MY story, not yours. I didn't think someone could sink so low. But I was wrong apparently. You're disgusting and stupid. Did you actually think that I wouldn't find out? For those of you that are reading this story, I apologize and would like to let you know that this story is posted under my name on the Warner Brothers Message Boards and hpfanfiction.com. I'm sorry for the inconvenience. If you want I can e-mail you the story. And it will be up on fanfiction.net soon. Until I clean this up though I can't post it here. -The Author


Name: lil_boo15 (Signed) · Date: 12/24/05 23:33 · For: The Dreadful News
I really like this story, its really intinse. I'm kinda confused though. So could you please explaine things?? j/w i think its really good though so please update as soon as you can!!!

Name: Lostlovegoods (Signed) · Date: 12/19/05 14:52 · For: Prologue
wonderful layout of how even in the worst and darkest times you can laugh and love...deffinately love. can't wait for the next one!*10*

Author's Response: thanks everyone for the reviews. but i have bad news. the dumb person in charge of validating the chapters was being rude and refused to validate it unitl i "cleared things up" just to let you know, that really really hurt me. here i am, trying my best to explain the things going on and somebody comes and tells me that my story isnt good enough. well i'd like to see if he/her story is any better! so my question is this: if i move my story over to harrypotterfanfiction.com will you guys still read it? because just to let you know, as i've heard from my family and friends, the story gets really good in the later chapters. okay well let me know soon please! -your sad author :(

Name: starrfleur (Signed) · Date: 12/19/05 7:17 · For: Where is Hope?
Ahh I love your story! Its intense yet not over-dramatic in an annoying way or anything! And it actually made me laugh out loud a few times, I loved the broom scene! "What the hell is that?... its a yellow cane with hair protruding out one end" or something like that. but yea haha. Its cool cuz you give us a break from all that seriousness with an occasional laugh! Awesome story! BETTER WRITE FAST CUZ I WANNA READ THE NEXT CHAPTER! :D

Name: Tinn Tam (Signed) · Date: 12/19/05 2:06 · For: Where is Hope?
Aaaaaand... added to favourites! For a change, an original start for a James/Lily romance fic! Looking forward to reading whatever happens next!

Name: Tinn Tam (Signed) · Date: 12/19/05 1:29 · For: Prologue
Perfect prologue. It immediately made me want to read the following chapters.

Name: Sirius Krummy Fan (Signed) · Date: 12/18/05 18:32 · For: Where is Hope?
Excellent! I loved it even if it was a bit confusing...Update soon! In my favs...10!

You must login (register) to review.