MuggleNet Fan Fiction
Harry Potter stories written by fans!
Reviews For Dear Dumby

Name: HermyRox12 (Signed) · Date: 08/08/06 19:47 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 5
Dear Dumby,
Once again I am terribly sorry that I didn't review this sooner. I hope you find some good advise to give again. I mean that water skiing worked. Maybe if you try that, you can get your mind flowing for better advise. I don't know. Anyway, tell the author that this chapter was great, especially the letter from Miserable. Good luck with the next chapter!

Author's Response: Dear HermyRox12, I have to say I'm rather stumped as for giving advice at the moment - everything seems to have backfired. Maybe I should try the water skiing, take a break... I will let the author know, she will be delighted to know that you enjoyed it! She also thanks you very much for reviewing! Love Dumby

Name: hermione_smiley (Signed) · Date: 08/08/06 7:54 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 5
Its the best humor fic.Thanks for giving me such laughs.i enjoyed it

Author's Response: Thank you! Oh, it's no problem - I'm really happy that I can make you laugh! Thank *you* for reading - and for reviewing!

Name: hermione_smiley (Signed) · Date: 08/08/06 7:54 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 5
Its the best humor fic.Thanks for giving me such laughs.i enjoyed it

Author's Response: See other review!

Name: Blonde_Babe (Anonymous) · Date: 08/08/06 2:15 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 5
hehe was the fumby writing to himself? lol! LOVE the story!

Author's Response: Yup - Dumby is getting desperate! Thanks!

Name: Blonde_Babe (Anonymous) · Date: 08/08/06 2:07 · For: In The Face Of Adversity…

Author's Response: THANK YOU!! *Giggles* I have to say, I really, really enjoyed writing this chapter! You know, when I saw Harry/Voldy, it made me think of the ship! Lol! I don't think things could ever get that weird though! But the confrontation between them was fun to do - especially with his breakdown! Thanks for reviewing!

Name: Blonde_Babe (Anonymous) · Date: 08/08/06 1:14 · For: Headbanging - Not To Be Taken Literally
haha i love it when harry bangs his head on the table! its the best part! lol great story!

Author's Response: Thank you! Well, desperate times call for desperate measures! (Look out for a return of the headbanging in chapter 10!)

Name: seeka blood (Signed) · Date: 08/06/06 12:40 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 5
what i don't get it

Author's Response: What exactly don't you get? If you could give me a bit more feedback on what exactly you didn't get, I'd happily explain it for you.

Name: Marsprincess (Signed) · Date: 08/05/06 9:55 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 1
It is hilarious and cute, you made it so obvios that Ron was trying so hard to not to be revealed which I thought was adorable. I also love Harry'd nickname "Fed Up Of Avoiding Avada Kedavera" I loved it" Keep it Up

Author's Response: Thank you! Yes, Ron's still (sort of!) in denial - but watch out for another let of his in chapter 11! I liked Harry's alias too, so I'm glad you liked it as well! Thanks for reviewing!

Name: _Hermione_Granger_ (Signed) · Date: 08/02/06 4:06 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 5
Brilliant story! cant wait for an update!

Author's Response: Thanks! Hopefully it will come soon!

Name: Hip_Hop_Muggle (Anonymous) · Date: 08/01/06 13:28 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 5
Awww! No Luna?! *puts on puppy-dog eyes and pouts*

Author's Response: Aw, I'm sorry! But it just wasn't right. I did have her make an entrance though! We'll see, maybe I'll do something in the future to incorperate her...

Name: Purplemage (Signed) · Date: 07/30/06 14:36 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 5
I can't believe it took me so long to read this, but I did it in the end and it was defenetley worth it! Because I'm in Spew now, I shall go and leave you a spew worthy review...

"Well, even the best advice can sometimes backfire. Now, I’m not saying I gave you the best advice, as bad advice can backfire too" This was the best line of the whole chapter, it's very Dumbledore of him to write something like this. I couldn't stop laughing and then I read it again on the other letters and I laughed even more. I loved Dumbledore in this chapter, he's quite confused. He wants to keep helping the others, but he doesn't want to get them into more trouble. Give advice or not give advice? That's the question!

I think that it would sound better if you changed Harry's name when Dumby replies from "Wizard On My Robes" to "Wizard On His Robes", but that's just me.

The un-named Gryffindor girl letter was soooo funny! I think that one was the funniest. "It seems like I’m not used for anything except to make up numbers" What a great line! i couldn't stop laughing. I think there should be two invisible Gryffindor girls, I guess the other one is even more invisible because she doesn't have a voice.

I really can't come with who Miserable is. I think it's Snape, but I'm not too sure. If it's him than I'm glad he's miserable; he deserves it.

The endind was awesome with Dumby writing at himself, it was so clever! Especially his reply to himslef "I have absolutely no idea." LOL, poor Albus.

I'm so sad that this story is almost over *sniff* It's the end of an era! *clings to Kiara* Ok, maybe not that much, but still it's sad.

Author's Response: Wow, many congrats in getting into SPEW! And thanks for giving me a spew worthy review - whoa! I think this might be the longest one I've ever gotten! *hugs Harald* Thank you!
I'm really pleased you liked Dumbledore in this chapter, as it was quite hard keeping him in character as well as slightly confused! But to be honest - who can blame him? After all those letters and outcomes, who wouldn't be?!
Will change Dumby's reply to Harry's name, thanks for catching it! To be honest, I was a little hesitant to include the Un-Named Gryffindor Girl, so I'm really glad you enjoyed that one! Yes, not sure where Invsi-Girl 2 is... Perhaps she got caught up in an unfortunate Potions mishap?
Nope, Miserable isn't Snape! (Lol, he does deserve it though!) It's someone who we've seen in the last chapter, who is finding his inner-self - well, basically having a bit of a breakdown! This person definitely deserves to be miserable too though!
You know, I think Dumby's reply is one of my favourite bits too! I thought it a nice way to end it. *sobs* Ohmygosh - it's actually ending! It's so strange - my first ever fanfic, coming to a close! *clings back to Harald* What are we going to do?! ...Write and read some more, I guess! And there's still the last chapter (which I'm really enjoying writing at the moment!)! Thank you for such a lovely review!

Name: mione_rox (Signed) · Date: 07/27/06 0:53 · For: In The Face Of Adversity…
that was bloody hilarius!!! i can just see voldy going on a huge self-pity rant. That was soooo funny. i think i lost my voice laughing so hard. And the fan girls, that was hilarious. and by the way, i especially love this story because it has dumbles, and dumbledore is my favorite character. LONG LIVE DUMBLES!!!!! I cant wait for the next chapter, when will it be back? anyway, great job!

100000000000000000000/10 WOO!

Author's Response: Ah, yes, good old Dumbledore! I'm so glad you're enjoying this - even if it is making you lose your voice - sorry about that! But, hey, laughter is great. The fan girls are one of my favourite parts, I have to admit! You know, with all the angst in Voldemort's life, he's got to be long overdue on a breakdown...! The next chapter will be...soon...ish? Hopefully! I'll keep you updated! Thanks for reviewing - and for breaking limits! WOO indeed!

Name: LunaRoxDaRadishes (Signed) · Date: 07/25/06 22:44 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 5
LoL, dear old Dumbles writing to himself...tsk tsk...he needs help. Not THAT kind of help, but...you know what I mean. Keep up the funniness! Yay funniness!

Author's Response: Thanks J-Mo! Yes, poor old Dumby definetely needs help of some sort - though he was meant to be the one giving it! I'll try to keep it up - thanks for reviewing!

Name: LunaRoxDaRadishes (Signed) · Date: 07/25/06 22:37 · For: In The Face Of Adversity…
Oh. My. God. I...think...my...spleen...just...burst. HAHAHA! Funniest chapter yet! I love how Hermione is planning on having that many children (hopefully she'll have an epideral...or however you spell it). I also love how Harry is trying to convince Voldemort to stay evil. Ooo! You could've made Harry be all, "You have to stay evil-for the good of the plot line!" Congrats on being funny!

Author's Response: Thank you! You know, after you've read the next chapter, you really ought to get that spleen looked at...! Yes, although I have to say I feel more sorry for Ron than Hermione, thinking about all of her children! 'Giggles' You know, Harry really ought to try that! Hey - desperate times call for desperate measures! Thanks for reviewing!

Name: sexi_lion (Signed) · Date: 07/25/06 21:21 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 5
the last one is cute!!! i really hope r/he hook up soon, H/G too

Author's Response: Thanks! I hope so too - but then, some things just aren't meant to be - life can be unfair...

Name: Youth (Anonymous) · Date: 07/25/06 14:07 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 5
Goodness! Poor Hermione, and poor Ron!

Author's Response: I know! Can't they ever get it right when it comes to each other?! We'll see, I suppose...!

Name: diary_girl (Signed) · Date: 07/24/06 22:16 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 5
lol! Maybe you could have Sirius Black write next...

Author's Response: Well, that would be a little hard, as the post office is notoriously slow through that veil - even with two first class stamps!

Name: Altoid_storm (Signed) · Date: 07/23/06 23:46 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 1
The Ron one was the best and the Filch one was the funniest.... wow. that was great.

Author's Response: See other review!

Name: Altoid_storm (Signed) · Date: 07/23/06 23:43 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 1
The Ron one was the best and the Filch one was the funniest.... wow. that was great.

Author's Response: I'm glad! I've got to say, writing Ron's was a lot of fun - I love writing Ron, I really do!

Name: murgatroid (Signed) · Date: 07/23/06 21:32 · For: Dear Dumby - Issue 5
*giggles uncontrollably* hehehe!!! thats excelent!!!!

Author's Response: Thanks!

You must login (register) to review.