MuggleNet Fan Fiction
Harry Potter stories written by fans!

Name: evil_fairy (Signed) · Date: 09/03/05 16:48 · For: Dogstar
Omg!! I absolutely loved that story!! I totally started to cry! You are a great writer and you should keep on writing! And thank you for reminding me of how much I miss Sirius...afterall he was my favorite character.

Author's Response: Ginny and Sirius are my favorite characters, so what better story than one with the both of them in a unique romance. With everyone crying, I think I need to go back and re-read my story. =)

Name: greenyoda987 (Signed) · Date: 09/03/05 12:49 · For: Dogstar
Yeah..I was crying! I was crying like a baby at the end. That was so touching. The way that you made Ginny be the one who kisses him first and just how he responed. And then when she was in astronomy class hearing about her 'Dogstar'. That was really a great story. You are a wonderful writer and I was really bummed to hear that this was the last chapeter. But I do think that you did an excelent job writing it. Thank you so much for everything and I cant wait to read more from you! _Claire

Author's Response: Wow I'm sorry I made everyone cry! I am glad that my story had a deep emotional effect though! Seeing these reviews tells me I'm doing a good job and it keeps me motivated to write more and more! I'm sorry it was the last chapter, but he died, I couldn't stop that, sadly! Thanks for being such a loyal fan!

Name: WitchatHeart77 (Signed) · Date: 09/03/05 12:41 · For: Dogstar
I had my reservations about this one.. but you did write it well...I was crying by the end of it and really loved the part about the Prof. Sinistra going over the Dogstar...(whimper)...good job.

Author's Response: I had reservations when I read Secret Friends by Harriet_Evans, but hers was so sweet. I wanted to write my own because I wanted the relationship to be deeper and longer. She allowed me to use the Dogstar idea in my story. Thanks for reviewing! I really appreciate it!

Name: Free_Phoenix (Signed) · Date: 08/30/05 6:50 · For: The Everlasting Flame
Brilliant, so sweet. I read Secret Friends and this could give it a run for its money! 10/10

Author's Response: Wow, I'm in awe. I would never personally compare myself to Alison because she's such a brilliant writer, but thanks so much for the kind review.

Name: greenyoda987 (Signed) · Date: 08/28/05 11:37 · For: The Everlasting Flame
Aww...that is so cute! I'm gonna go read it again! God this is getting so good. You are not going to be put on my favorites list. You are a wonderful author and I cant say that enough. I cant wait to see where this goes. Thanks so much for posting and happy writing!

Author's Response: Thanks so much for all of your reviews. It really keeps me motivated. I have already finished the story, but I'm hesitating to post the final chapter because I think he smiles way too much. That's what happens when you're in love though.

Name: greenyoda987 (Signed) · Date: 08/28/05 0:10 · For: The Letter
AWWWWW!!! That's so great! I love where this story is heading! And I really like this pairing...I didn't think that I would but I do. Maybe it's because of the way that you write. You can really get into a characters heart, pouring out what they feel to the reader. Very good. Please keep on posting! Cant wait to read more! Oh...I cant wait to see how Sirius reacts! GROWL ::sexy dog-man comes after wild, red-haired-girl:: Anyway, please keep on posting and I'll keep on reading! Thanks - Claire

Author's Response: Chapter 3 has already been submitted, so keep checking back. Glad you are enjoying it!

Name: Free_Phoenix (Signed) · Date: 08/18/05 7:18 · For: Padfoot and Wild Fire
Fantastic - I didn't think Ginny and Sirius as a couple would work, but you could just make it. More chapter please!

Author's Response: There's only one more chapter left for reasons I am sure everyone knows if you've read the canon. *tear* I've been putting off finishing it because I love the story so much, but I should be working on it soon because I have new stories I want to add and I don't want too many to update at a time.

Name: GRIFFINDORSTUDENT (Signed) · Date: 08/13/05 9:17 · For: Padfoot and Wild Fire
Well done! I loved the scene at the end when she reflects on encountering him as dog... I am correct in that she either knows or strongly suspects that was Sirius? I also like the pairing, having read Secret Friends, prior, and can't wait to see where you take them.

Author's Response: Actually she didn't know it was him. In my head I'm assuming she found out when they arrived at Grimmauld Place, or she heard it from the Trio. But at the time, No, she didn't know.

Name: Harriet Evans (Anonymous) · Date: 08/08/05 1:09 · For: Padfoot and Wild Fire
That was good - I thought you had the characters down very well. I liked the initial interchange between them on the roof (I am partial to a bit of star gazing - hee, hee) and thought his name for her was very good. Lovely twist at the end where she had encountered him as a dog - I didn't expect that! Think I would have been tempted to miss out your narrative comment that it would be a while before either of them realised who the other was though - I think this is clear from the story telling already and it would add to the charm a bit by letting the idea form in the reader's mind. that's my only concrit though - hope you don't mind. Otherwise, very excellent. Oh, and thanks so much for the ad!

Author's Response: I'll take that into mind, I was thinking the same thing myself after I submitted it. And to your ad, your story speaks for itself. It doesn't need an ad! =)

Name: HerEviLMajesty (Signed) · Date: 08/07/05 11:40 · For: Padfoot and Wild Fire
very strange pairing indeed. i like it though, i mean, i'm not so keen on the age difference, but i think that they could work. keep up with the story..i'll be waiting for more. 10/10. :)

You must login (register) to review.