Reviewer: I-luv-Hogwarts
Date: 05/17/09 13:11
Chapter: Moving On

I just read your story, i'm sorry that I didn't rewiew sooner, i was too caught-up in your really really good story.
Here is the answer to some of your questions:
My favorite LKR charecter was Sirius, you made him so funny!
My favorite charecter of your invention was Katy, she is the most like me.
I hated Venus the most, she was really terrible, and mean. I didn't have a fav chapter, that were all really good!!!
If possible could you make the chapters slightly longer, you don't have to, I mean i'm just one person but i would really like it.
I am really looking forward to your sequel. I-L-H

Reviewer: ron lover
Date: 04/08/09 19:40
Chapter: Moving On

i LOVED this story

Reviewer: ron lover
Date: 04/08/09 15:28
Chapter: Gossip

this is my favorite chapter so far. it is soo funny

Reviewer: Cascia
Date: 03/18/09 0:13
Chapter: Spirit Broken

Just a side note here... The marauders map doesn't show the room of requirement on it, therefore they wouldn't know where sirius was because he wouldn't appear on the map

Reviewer: amandafink
Date: 03/09/09 22:34
Chapter: She Returns

"healthy draught??" come on, you can do better than that.

Reviewer: harryslover_silverlining_88
Date: 03/04/09 16:58
Chapter: The Beautiful Friendship Begins

wow what i great fic i just finished reading the whole thing and it seemed to get better as it progressed

Reviewer: BeautyInTheBreakdown
Date: 01/27/09 23:17
Chapter: Moving On

What was your favorite quote in L/J: Their Story of Love? I don't have time for that, it's 60 chapters long!

Who was your favorite JKR created character? (ex. Sirius, Lily, James, Remus) I love Sirius, always.

Who was your favorite OC? (ex. Katy, Halle) Grace. I think she's pretty.

Which villain did you hate the most? (ex. Venus, Cole, Voldemort, Peter?) Venus

Who was your favorite couple? I like James and Lily... even though they broke up way too much.

Is there anything you didn’t like story-related? (I’m not speaking of grammar.) What happened after they were trapped in the firey trees with the snakes?? Hello! They like pass out and then they're walking around Howarts...

Well, All in all, it was not bad. afew critiques that may help future stories, the chapters were very short and this story could have been shortened to about 30 chapters. Also, try to keep the characters IN character... I realize this is your story and OOC is my least favourite thing to get yelled at for (my characters are said to be a bit out of character and it bugs me) but there are points that are just not believable at all and take away from the character, such as when Dumbledore gets drunk. That wouldn't happen. My last complaint is the language. Yes, it's fun to excercize your freedom of speech once in a while, but there are other ways to address someone other than "dumb bitch". Excessive foul language takes away from the meaning of the story and the effect of the sentences following it wears of.

Just a bit of hopefully helpful advice. I enjoyed it.

PS, you apparently like Marauders, so you might want to check out my story, Alone if you get the time

Best wishes,

Reviewer: olipop10
Date: 01/24/09 17:40
Chapter: No Mercy

i would have broken voldemorts wand.
but this chapter is full of emotions, it really got me into it!!!
is she really never going to heal??

Reviewer: olipop10
Date: 01/24/09 17:23
Chapter: Twice Defied

very good action.
the vounter spell for Colloportus is Alohomora, a death eater used it in book 5 in the departement of mysteries when they were searching for Harry and the others in the multiple rooms of the departement of mysteries. so i think that the death eaters were not as stupid as to not think of alohomara to open the door. neither voldemort.
anyway, like the action. im keeping on reading :)

Reviewer: olipop10
Date: 01/24/09 17:05
Chapter: Picking Lilies

how did voldemort get there? on the giant crow? but again, its not possible to get out of the castle using a portkey, Hermione always said so to Harry, reference: Hogwarts, a history. due to the wards, it is impossible to come and go to and from the grounds and the castle by any magical means, apart from the room of requirements and floo powder(only when the channel is opened though) and again, by walking through the gates.

Reviewer: olipop10
Date: 01/23/09 16:32
Chapter: Dreams

now with DH, we know that james didn"t really had the time to duel with voldemort because he had lef his wand on the couch. we can see that in the chapter just after harry and hermione's narrow escape from bathilda"s house in godric"s hollow !;

anyway, i like the idea of them having like premonitions.


Reviewer: olipop10
Date: 01/23/09 15:55
Chapter: Wisdom of Dumbledore

james isn't moved more than that of his parents' death??? strange

Reviewer: olipop10
Date: 01/23/09 15:14
Chapter: Arrival of Fear

hum hum, so far the story is very interesting :)

but the thing that made me write was about an unclear point i saw in this chapter: the portkey that took them away from voldy, it make them land in the castle??? because, because of all the wards and protection spells around hogwarts, it is impossible to enter the grounds of the school by any other means than by walking through the gates (even dumbledore had to undo some spells to fly in on broomstick on the night of his death). well, thats why i wrote.

anyway, the story is pretty good so far, so i'll keep on reading until the end, i love james/lily fanfics!


Reviewer: delirioustk
Date: 12/27/08 1:02
Chapter: Meeting with Dumbledore

:) i really like how the story is proceeding so far...can't wait to read more!

Reviewer: Magic Marauder
Date: 11/05/08 14:43
Chapter: Questions

wow Peter must be horrible! I AM SO HAPPY PETER STRANGLES HIMSELF I N DH! wow i get into it...its just a fic Caroline...just a fic

Reviewer: Magic Marauder
Date: 11/05/08 14:39
Chapter: A Friend's Betrayal

didnt he stop for a moment to think, I thought this was an anti prefects club! IDIOT!

Reviewer: Magic Marauder
Date: 11/04/08 17:10
Chapter: Dreams

its like im looking from a distance standing in the backround everybodys saying hes not coming home now this cant be happening to me this is just a dream....i thought of that song again.

Reviewer: Magic Marauder
Date: 11/04/08 17:05
Chapter: Clouded Feelings

weird...i alsways imagined Halle the impulsive one...btw is it Hal-e or Haall like long a? i think of the weirdest things!

Reviewer: Magic Marauder
Date: 11/04/08 16:58
Chapter: Wisdom of Dumbledore

omg!!!!! i wanted to review this the first time but i was too young...anyways my fourth grade teacher always said "Caroline, your writing has so much fluff." it would get me so agrivated!!!! and now that you said that that chapter was fluff, i relize that fluffyness is not such a bad thing...

Reviewer: Magic Marauder
Date: 11/04/08 16:54
Chapter: Arrival of Fear

i remember it took me like two weeks to get up to this chapter, this time its taking me two!

You must login (register) to review.
Find out everything you need to know about the site right here.

We have stories and authors in this archive.


Choose Theme:
A Story for Charlie by Darkness Enshrouds 3rd-5th Years
A boy. A girl. A budding romance. If only things never got complicated... (Violence...
Scorpius Malfoy and the Salem Witch Trials by Hotrav 3rd-5th Years
The third story in the Scorpius Malfoy and the Sins of the Fathers series. Lucius...
No One Can Ever Know by Nagini Riddle 3rd-5th Years
"My word, Severus, that I shall never reveal the best of you?"~Dumbledore to...
My Troubled Tyrant by Belledeg Professors
Keedie Dante has experienced many amazing things during her time at Hogwarts...
His and Hers by Acacia Carter 3rd-5th Years
In a perfect world, Neville and Hannah's wedding would go off without a hitch...
All This Waiting For The Sky To Fall by Dawnie 1st-2nd Years
They found her body - broken, bleeding, face filled with signs of pain and fear...
Sanguini, the Vampire by teh tarik 6th-7th Years
Vampirism is the persistence and the perpetuity of the body, a madness of the...
Lost and Found by ToBeOrNotToBeAGryffindor 3rd-5th Years
When Tracey Davis's financial security was a casualty of war, her family is...