MuggleNet Fan Fiction
Harry Potter stories written by fans!
Reviews For Promise Me

Name: tufgurl (Signed) · Date: 10/21/05 17:47 · For: Journey to Azkaban
i have question.. if aime was a marauder was she an animagus too? wat form did she take?

Name: Lumos (Signed) · Date: 05/30/05 5:34 · For: Promise Me
That was... heartbreaking. A beautiful end to a beautiful story. That is all I have to say.

Name: Lumos (Signed) · Date: 05/10/05 11:38 · For: Dealt a poor hand.
Ooooooh, it really is getting intereting now, isn't it? Poor old Sirius! Can't wait to find out what happens next!

Name: Lumos (Signed) · Date: 04/04/05 5:38 · For: Best man - Second best
Loved the intimacy in this chapter, but I can't help feeling suspicious of Arella. I assume I'm meant to?

Author's Response: Hello Lumos! Yes you are meant to feel a little suspicious..you'll see soon. Thank you for all your reviews.

Name: Kerian (Signed) · Date: 03/28/05 14:29 · For: Best man - Second best
I like that James and Sirius can disagree and still be okay. I really hope Lily's vision isn't right!! And I love Sirius for trying to be a good boy lol! great chapter :)

Author's Response: Oh I have been away far too long! Lol I'm so pleased you enjoyed this, and thank you for reviewing.

Name: Kerian (Signed) · Date: 03/22/05 18:50 · For: The End of the Innocence
They were soo close! Aww I loved the chapter! And I loved that through the entire convo with Snape Arella was completely in control! And I love that James just had to come in the fireplace, and Arella's answer was so perfect. I'm sure its going to set the tone for chapters to come! 10 for 10 as always!

Author's Response: Yes, she's a good match for Snape. Naughty James for coming at the wrong moment, but it will work out for the better, for a while. Thank you for reviewing.

Name: MrsBlack212 (Anonymous) · Date: 03/22/05 17:45 · For: The End of the Innocence
I loved that chapter. It made me want to be with Sirius, hence, the name. I really liked this chapter a whole lot, make more like it!

Author's Response: Awe, thank you Mrs Black. I know I've got it right when a Sirius fan like yourself approves. I'll update soon.

Name: Lumos (Signed) · Date: 03/19/05 7:24 · For: The End of the Innocence
Wow, that chapter was intense! I couldn't have stopped reading that for the world. Loved the way you built up the tension between Sirius and Arella to such a pitch, which only served to give James' entry and words all the more impact. Beautifully written too. Your best chapter so far I'd say.

Author's Response: Thank you! That's so nice to hear, because I had problems taming this chapter. It's always good to know that it's worked.

Name: Lumos (Signed) · Date: 03/15/05 8:51 · For: Chess
Once again I loved this chapter. I LOVED the description of Arella as an exquisite bird who could not be caged by marriage. Incredibly vivid and it just brings into sharp relief Sirius' love for her. I can't wait for more.

Author's Response: Thank you. That phrase actually has special significance in one of my later stories. I'm hoping to load the next chapter today. Thank you once again.

Name: Kerian (Signed) · Date: 03/14/05 8:06 · For: Chess
Oo Im excited to see what happens next! This was my FAVORITE chapter so far! I loved it! I loved seeing the socializing with all the Slytherin families, and I love that they wanted to control Arella and Sirius would never go for it. Another great great chapter! Well done as always! 10 for 10! Are we going to keep going forward, or jump back at all to when they were still in school?

Author's Response: From now on it will go forward, though we will hear from Sirius trapped in Azkaban again. Thank you for your wonderful review.

Name: HarryandDracoLove (Signed) · Date: 03/13/05 8:47 · For: The Birthday Bond
I am so glad to read a Sirius Black fanfic. I absolutely love him and all my friends think I'm crazy! Great work! I would give you a higher rating if I could, but thats as far as it goes.

Author's Response: I really enjoy writing about Sirius, though this is a first attempt. Thank you for your kind review!

Name: Lumos (Signed) · Date: 03/12/05 4:33 · For: The Birthday Bond
By the time I'd finished chapter two, this story was on my favourites list. Now I've finished chapter three, it's not only on my favourites list, but at the very top of the pile. I love it. I get sick and tired of reading stories with immaculate reviews that are in fact not very well written, even if the plot is gripping. This has both - it makes me want to read more and your style of writing is wonderful to read. Well done!

Author's Response: Lumos, I have never had such reviews, and I cannot express my gratitude! The story itself is very nearly finished and I hope to update here soon. There will be about another 4/5 chapters. Thank you as every for your praise and taking the time to review. It means a great deal.

Name: lucillaq (Signed) · Date: 03/12/05 3:59 · For: The Birthday Bond
Great work! Can't wait for an update! I love her character!

Author's Response: HEllo Lucillaq. I'm so pleased you like Arella. This wasn't the first thing I wrote for her, but I think it's the better one. Perhaps one day I'll get to publishing my other story here too. Thank you for your kind review.

Name: Kerian (Signed) · Date: 03/11/05 14:25 · For: The Birthday Bond
Aww a cute chapter! Im still looking forward to seeing what happened at the dance, but I like that we skip around to seeing all the important parts. I love her rebelliousness and I like that Arella and James dont see eye to eye. It makes the group dynamics a lot more real! Another great chapter 10 for 10!

Name: Lumos (Signed) · Date: 03/10/05 11:42 · For: Blinded
I have absolutely no criticism to make of this chapter. Loved it! I think this story's just made it to my favourites list.

Author's Response: I am honoured! Thank you again for all your praise. It is comments like these that make my writing worthwhile so thank you.

Name: Lumos (Signed) · Date: 03/10/05 11:27 · For: Journey to Azkaban
Beautifully poetic, wonderfully fluid. Possibly a little too poetic in places - Sirius sounded incongruously Shakesperean when he was talking to Arella, particularly given his circumstances, so a little more colloquialism might have been good here. However, in terms of style and language, this is still about a million times better than any other fan fiction I've read so well done!

Author's Response: Gosh, thank you Lumos. Sirius in the beginning was hard to do as it's hard to know exactly how you could even begin to talk to anyone in those circumstances, but talk he must. I suspect he has mingled with an excellent Lucius fic I was reading and the 'Shakespearean' language comes from that - that combined with my own! Your last comments astound me. Thank you so much for taking the time to review.

Name: lucillaq (Signed) · Date: 03/09/05 23:37 · For: Blinded
I have just read both chapters! This is a wonderful story! Can't wait for an update!

Author's Response: The update will be in the next day or so. I'm so glad you're enjoying it and thank you for taking the time to review.

Name: snuffles2984 (Signed) · Date: 03/09/05 17:15 · For: Blinded
This is really very good. Very well written. Your words flow very gracefully and really make your descriptions very vivid. Great plot so far as well. Keep it up!!

Author's Response: Thank you Snuffles. I was told it was a little too descriptive, but I think it needs that to create atmosphere. Thank you very much for taking the time to review and I hope to update soon.

Name: Kerian (Signed) · Date: 03/09/05 12:19 · For: Blinded
Such a good chapter! Your doing so well with this story! I love the way you portray the boys as constantly playful, and I love your twist that Arella and Snape were together. I cant wait to see the chapter about the dance! Great writing!

Author's Response: Thank you again Kerian. The next chapter will jump a little but you will get to see a bit more about Arella and Snape as the story progresses. Thank you so much for your kind reviews.

Name: Kerian (Signed) · Date: 03/08/05 14:43 · For: Journey to Azkaban
Awesome Awesome start! I loved it! Is it going to be in present time? or going back in time to see how she and Sirius first met? I cant wait for the update!

Author's Response: Hi Kerian. It will go back in time to how they first met and their history, plus the Marauders too. I added the next chapter already so fingers crossed for an update soon.

You must login (register) to review.