Savoring Fortescue's Finest Ice Cream
I disagree with this... As long as there is another plausible explanation, I don't think that we can blame JKR like that...
Originally Posted by Tim the Enchanter
At my school, we had a, b and c classes in each year. There was nothing really different about them, just a way to split the 100 students per year up. Since we didn't have mixed PE (so boys and girls had their own teachers) those classes were smaller, and we got mixed with one other class from the year. Some years it'd be a+b together in PE, and c alone, and then another time a+c, ...
I think it's just as likely that maybe in Ginny's year, there weren't a lot of students sorted into Gryffindor (I don't think we ever get to know anyone she shares her dormitory with, do we?), and they thought that having a class with four Gryffindors and another one with five Ravenclaws was just stupid, so they combined them.
And since in Harry's year there were enough Gryffindors to sensibly hold a class with, it wasn't necessary to have them share a class.
(Or maybe Ginny and Luna never shared that class, but Ginny told those boys off right before/after the class... or she had detention with McGonnagal and so she sat in the back of that class...)
This completely gorgeous banner, which makes me happier than a squirrel, was made by Hokey