wendelin the wierd: Well firstly I'd like to say your bannermaking skills are anything but rusty if these three banners are anything to go by! I really like all of them. I would say number 1 is the best (my prefrence anyway). The colours and softness in the first banner really emphasise the feeling of closeness of the couple. I also like the brush you have used. In the second and third, I feel the colour is too bright for the feeling the quote evokes, as if it's overpowering the image. I think that is why the first banner works so well. I love your use of font and the way it is set out compared to the couple. I also like the your use of the copy of the same line of text and having one line fading, it adds a very nice touch!
I hope that was okay for you wendelin as I've never done this banner critique before!
Well I've been making banners for a few weeks now and never had the courage to show any of them...so here goes, this is a character banner for Ginny Weasley
medium to harsh critique thanks, I want to improve!