Oh My Gordic, Tim, I had read about your character but had never visited this thread. Now I've read all the posts (yes, all of them), and Dieter is such a great character that I want to slap him. Or exorcise him. Anyways, I couldn't resist stopping by to ask a few questions, because he is addicting, kind of like trying to convince strong conservatives to accept gay marriage, or Laura Mallory to read Harry Potter. It's basically the equivalent of beating your head against a brick wall, but you can't keep from trying!
Guten Tag, Dieter! I am here to question you...
In that case, could they be good sub humans? I mean, there are some pretty nice cats and dogs out there… (I feel so weird asking this.)Can a Slav or a Jew or any other Untermensch be a good person?
Well, they're not even fully human, so no.
So… you say that you can't prove the existence of a subhuman soul. I can accept that. But that means that you can't prove that you have a soul either. Which means it is impossible to compare a subhuman and Aryan soul, because you can't even prove souls exist. In which case you can only compare their physical traits. So what this means is that basically Aryans are better merely because they are blonder, have bluer eyes, and are apparently stronger… is that the case?
You also say that Untermenschen have animal-like minds, and "lack the ability to feel or comprehend what it is to be fully human". In that case, wouldn't it be wrong to hate them for not being human, and for actions that, being animals, they aren't fully responsible for? It would be kind of like hitting a kitten because it instinctively scratched you…
Here's a little sample of my background: I'm part Spanish, Italian, Basque, American Indian, and yes, part Aryan. Would you trust me?
I've lived in Brazil, the US, and France. Does this change your answer at all, or does only my race matter?
Does it bother you sometimes that you clearly have less knowledge of the Wizarding World than pure or half-blood wizards? I mean, you didn't know what a Boggart or Patronus was…
Since the Jewish religion is obviously a race to you, what would you think of an Aryan who, for whatever reason, decided to renounce Christianity and join the Jewish religion?
What was your favorite book when you were younger?
That's all for now...I'll probably come back for more, you little Nazi - sorry, National Socialist.