Results 1 to 8 of 8

Thread: 2017 QSQ Judging Sign-Ups!

  1. #1
    Queen of Foals Slytherin
    Unspeakable
    Kill the Spare
    the opaleye's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    Mirkwood
    Posts
    1,842

    2017 QSQ Judging Sign-Ups!

    2017 QSQ Judging Sign-Ups!

    Judging in this year's QSQs will be done, as usual, by committees who hold confidential discussions and vote on the winners.

    If you would like to sign up, please post below using the form. Please think before you sign up and make sure that you are totally happy with what judging requires. You will be expected to be available fairly frequently during the months of July and August (needing occasional weeks off is fine, but if you know you're only going to be around for a couple of days during this time, please don't sign up) and you must be prepared to read all the nominations in your category. Please think about the types of stories you would be prepared to read (remember nominations can be any rating and contain any warnings) and avoid categories you would feel uncomfortable reading. You may not enjoy everything you read, but it is still important that you give a fair, balanced opinion. If you think you won't have as much time, then we would suggest asking for a smaller category.


    • Best General Story (contains best General, Mystery, History, Marauder Era, Humor, and Alternate Universe fics)
    • Best Dark/Angsty Story
    • Best New Canon Story
    • Best Canon Romance Story (contains the SSP of Dumbledore/Grindelwald)
    • Best Non-Canon Romance Story (contains all other SSPs)
    • Best Poetry
    • Best Post-Hogwarts/Next Generation Story


    The final thing to note is that we keep the entire judging process secret. This means that you may not reveal anywhere which category you are judging, or express any opinions on nominations outside the judging forums. If your committee does decide on a winner before the final deadline, it goes without saying that you shouldn't post the results anywhere. We also expect that once a decision has been made by a committee, all members of that committee will support it, even if it is not for a story they voted for.

    We know it all sounds rather scary but being on a committee is a great way to be involved in one of the most anticipated MNFF events of the year, and you may find yourself reading and enjoying stories you'd never have considered before. So long as you are clear about what is expected, and can set aside time for reading and writing brief opinions on stories, then it is not a huge commitment. And committees are vital in the running of the awards. The fewer judges we get, the fewer people who have a say in the final decision and the less representative the decision becomes.

    Here is the form to use for sign-ups:

    PHP Code:
    [B]Do you fully understand the rules and commitment required to be QSQ judge?[/B]
    [
    B]How many committees would you be prepared to sit on?[/B]
    [
    B]Are there any categories you are particularly keen to judge?[/B]
    [
    B]Are there any categories you would not be happy to judge?[/B]
    [
    B]Would you be prepared to lead a committee if necessary?[/B] (This means assigning committee members stories to readleading discussions and chasing people up to post their comments/votesYou must have participated in QSQ judging in a previous year to lead a committee)
    [
    B]Can you think of any potential problems/issues that would affect your ability to judge?[/B]  
    Feel free to add in any details you think are necessary
    Committees won't be appointed until nominations have closed to ensure no one is asked to be on a committee they've been nominated for. This thread will be open until June 30th or until nominations have closed.
    Last edited by the opaleye; 05-29-2017 at 10:05 AM.

    Banner by Lydia. Icon from toreadabook on lj.

  2. #2
    Seventh Year Slytherin
    "Greetings From Egypt..."
    Oregonian's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Location
    The green and rainy Pacific Northwest
    Posts
    830
    Do you fully understand the rules and commitment required to be QSQ judge?
    Yes.

    How many committees would you be prepared to sit on?
    I have done two at a time in the past, but I think I could manage three, if necessary, though not to lead more than two.

    Are there any categories you are particularly keen to judge?
    I feel equally about all of them.

    Are there categories you would not be happy to judge?
    No, I will judge whatever category you need me to do.

    Would you be prepared to lead a committee if necessary?
    Yes.

    Can you think of any potential problems/issues that would affect your ability to judge?
    Not really. I will be away at a conference August 3-6, but that should be no problem.
    Edit: June 19, 2017. It looks as if I will be at another conference also, from July 30 to August 3 in Vancouver, BC, but hopefully I will be able to work on QSQ stuff in the evenings.
    Last edited by Oregonian; 06-20-2017 at 12:16 AM.
    Writer, Poet, Drabbler, Occasional Beta, Slytherin Cheerleader
    [center]
    This lovely banner is a gift from my good friend Nagini Riddle.

  3. #3
    Seventh Year Hufflepuff
    Enemies of the Heir, Beware...of the Petrified Cat!
    Weasley Mom's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    550
    Do you fully understand the rules and commitment required to be QSQ judge?Yes
    How many committees would you be prepared to sit on? 2
    Are there any categories you are particularly keen to judge? Canon romance
    Are there any categories you would not be happy to judge? NCR, Poetry, New Canon (since I've not read CC)
    Would you be prepared to lead a committee if necessary? Never have, so only if you are really stuck.
    Can you think of any potential problems/issues that would affect your ability to judge?Nope
    Avatar by Annalise
    Banner by Julia

  4. #4
    Third Year Ravenclaw
    I'm a what?
    fynnsmom's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2015
    Posts
    72
    Do you fully understand the rules and commitment required to be QSQ judge? Yes.
    How many committees would you be prepared to sit on? As many as you need me to sit on.
    Are there any categories you are particularly keen to judge? Anything but poetry.
    Are there any categories you would not be happy to judge? I am really not good with poetry.
    Would you be prepared to lead a committee if necessary? (This means assigning committee members stories to read, leading discussions and chasing people up to post their comments/votes. You must have participated in QSQ judging in a previous year to lead a committee) If I had to I would but I think that leadership role is better held by someone more experienced. I am willing to learn though, if necessary.
    Can you think of any potential problems/issues that would affect your ability to judge? No
    Feel free to add in any details you think are necessary.

  5. #5
    Fourth Year Gryffindor
    Earning Points for Sheer Dumb Luck
    Kerichi's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    165
    Do you fully understand the rules and commitment required to be QSQ judge? Yes
    How many committees would you be prepared to sit on? 3
    Are there any categories you are particularly keen to judge? Poetry!
    Are there any categories you would not be happy to judge? They're all good
    Would you be prepared to lead a committee if necessary? If you're desperate.
    Can you think of any potential problems/issues that would affect your ability to judge? No

  6. #6
    Apple Wood Hufflepuff
    Unspeakable
    McGonagall Doesn't Expel Brilliant Seekers
    Padfoot11333's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    505
    Do you fully understand the rules and commitment required to be QSQ judge? Yes
    How many committees would you be prepared to sit on? 2
    Are there any categories you are particularly keen to judge? No
    Are there any categories you would not be happy to judge? New Canon
    Would you be prepared to lead a committee if necessary? (This means assigning committee members stories to read, leading discussions and chasing people up to post their comments/votes. You must have participated in QSQ judging in a previous year to lead a committee) Yes
    Can you think of any potential problems/issues that would affect your ability to judge?
    Feel free to add in any details you think are necessary.
    No although I am working around 50 hours a week at the moment so I am pretty busy!
    ♥♥♥ Lily Writes ♥♥♥



    Banner by the opaleye. Avi by TM_Wandstick.

  7. #7
    Second Year Gryffindor
    Setting Snakes on Hapless Relatives

    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Posts
    34
    Do*you*fully*understand*the*rules*and*commitment*r equired*to*be*QSQ*judge?n Yes
    How*many*committees*would*you*be*prepared*to*sit*o n? One
    Are*there*any*categories*you*are*particularly*keen *to*judge? General, Next Gen. I also like Dark/Angsty.
    Are*there*any*categories*you*would*not*be*happy*to *judge? Romance, Poetry
    Would*you*be*prepared*to*lead*a*committee*if*neces sary? *(This*means*assigning*committee*members*stories*t o*read,*leading*discussions*and*chasing*people*up* to*post*their*comments/votes.*You*must*have*participated*in*QSQ*judging*i n*a*previous*year*to*lead*a*committee) Yes
    Can*you*think*of*any*potential*problems/issues*that*would*affect*your*ability*to*judge?**No
    Feel*free*to*add*in*any*details*you*think*are*nece ssary.*

    Thanks! I've really enjoyed judging in the past and hope I get the opportunity again.

    Robin

  8. #8
    Ebil Minion Ravenclaw
    Receiving Toilet Seats
    BrokenPromise's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Location
    On the internet more often than off it
    Posts
    429
    Do you fully understand the rules and commitment required to be QSQ judge? yes
    How many committees would you be prepared to sit on? 2, 3 if small ones
    Are there any categories you are particularly keen to judge? poetry, ncr
    Are there any categories you would not be happy to judge? new canon
    Would you be prepared to lead a committee if necessary? yes but only 1
    Can you think of any potential problems/issues that would affect your ability to judge? no
    [@Bannermaking] [@Poetry] [@Writing] [@Drabbling] [@Duelling]

    Incredible Avvie and Beautiful banner for my Cotillion fic by Nadia/majestic_ginny!



Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •