I noticed that a lot of the banners in the old thread were disappearing as the older members moved on from MNFF, so I pestered Anna for everything she had and re-uploaded them to Photobucket, all in one place.
Even though some of them are quite old and hardly any of you know the people who made them, I thought it would be good to keep them in the SPEW forum for posterity. So I'm going to repost them all here! And if you're artistically-inclined, feel free to make your own and post them in here too.
If you use any, please credit the original bannermaker!